Names some actions (captures baselines, implements changes, invokes review, records outcomes) but they are generic process steps rather than concrete domain-specific actions. 'Optimization attempts' is vague—optimization of what?

Provides a vague 'what' but completely lacks a 'when' clause or any explicit trigger guidance. There is no indication of when Claude should select this skill over others.

No natural keywords a user would say. Terms like 'coordinates optimization attempts', 'captures baselines', and 'records outcomes' are abstract process language, not terms users would naturally use when requesting help.

'Optimization' is extremely broad and could apply to code optimization, performance tuning, SEO, database queries, image compression, or countless other domains. No domain specificity to distinguish it from other skills.

Generally efficient but has some redundancy — the 'Hunt DOES / Hunt does NOT' section repeats information that's implicit in the workflow phases. The role clarification section could be tighter. However, most of the content earns its place with specific commands and clear instructions.

Provides fully executable bash commands, specific file paths, concrete variable assignments, and exact command-line invocations. Each phase has copy-paste ready commands with clear parameter substitution patterns.

Excellent multi-step workflow with clear sequencing (Phases 0-5), explicit validation checkpoints (ci/validate must pass before proceeding), cleanup of stale data before baseline capture, and clear error handling guidance (pre-existing bug documentation). The feedback loop for ci/validate failure is explicit.

References external slash commands (/lading-preflight, /lading-optimize-find-target, /lading-optimize-review) and template files appropriately, but the skill itself is fairly long with all content inline. The bundle has no supporting files provided, so we can't verify the referenced template or db.yaml paths. The structure is reasonable but the inline content is substantial.