Mostly efficient and actionable, but includes some explanatory rationale Claude could infer (e.g., the 'Why you should not explore the codebase' section and repeated parenthetical justifications such as 'since hardcoded versions drift out of sync'). Tightening these would reach level 3.

Concrete file paths, a copy-paste Java delegation snippet, exact Granite resource type mappings, and explicit MCP tool-call arguments give fully executable guidance.

Clearly numbered, sequenced workflow with explicit validation checkpoints — the configuration gate, the dialog-spec echo-back confirmation, and step 3.11 dependency verification — plus a completion summary that serves as a final verification step.

Body is an overview that signals one-level-deep references inline per task and consolidates them in a Reference Files table; all 15 references and the field-type-mappings asset exist on disk and are loaded on-demand rather than inlined.

Lists multiple concrete actions — 'dialog, HTL template, Sling Model, unit tests, and clientlibs', 'extends Core Components', 'translates it into pixel-perfect HTL, CSS, and JS' — rather than vague language.

Explicitly answers both 'what' (creates complete AEM components with the listed artifacts) and 'when' via the explicit 'Use this skill whenever...' trigger clause.

Good coverage of natural user terms: 'creating, building, generating, or scaffolding', plus concrete component types (teaser, card, hero, accordion, tabs, carousel) and 'extend a Core Component', 'create a component dialog', 'convert a Figma design'.

AEM-specific niche with distinct triggers (component types, Core Component extension, Figma design conversion) makes it unlikely to fire for the wrong skill.