Content
85%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is an exceptionally concrete orchestration script: verbatim prompts, dispatch tables, a config template, confirmation gates, and correction loops leave little ambiguity about what to do at each step. Its main weaknesses are repetition of the --auto/doc-scan-only behavior across three sections, and a bundle whose referenced agent/shared files are missing while its one shipped reference file is orphaned — which hurts navigation more than the in-file structure deserves.
Suggestions
Link references/spectrum-s2-upgrade.md from SKILL.md (e.g. in the Supporting Files section or wherever Admin UI web-src migration is discussed) — it is currently shipped but unreachable from the skill body.
Ensure all referenced bundle files (agents/analyzer.md, agents/events.md, agents/webhooks.md, agents/admin-ui-sdk.md, agents/business-config.md, agents/executor.md, shared/schema.md, shared/questions.md, shared/migration-warnings.md, shared/references.md) actually ship with the skill, since Steps 1–5 cannot execute without them.
State the doc-scan-only and --auto behaviors once (in the Confirmation protocol) and have Step 1/Step 3/Notes reference that section instead of re-specifying them; consider moving the metadata derivation rules into a shared/ file to slim the body.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense, operational, and explains nothing Claude already knows — every block is an instruction, template, or rule. Minor trimming is possible: the doc-scan-only flow is fully specified twice (Confirmation protocol and again in Step 1's early-exit), and the Notes section recaps the --auto summary, env-var handling, and productDependencies rules already stated in Steps 3–4. That duplication is more than nothing but well short of the 'several unnecessary explanations' anchor at 3. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is fully executable: exact agent dispatch instructions with file paths and payloads ('Pass mode = "doc-scan-only"... Pass the ProjectSnapshot JSON... Pass assembled config = null'), a complete defineConfig TypeScript template, a confidence→agent mapping table, verbatim output blocks, and precise metadata derivation rules (normalization steps, 50-char limits, boilerplate names to skip). Concrete specifics cover the common cases with no pseudocode. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The Preflight → Step 1–5 sequence is explicit with validation at every risky point: preflight file checks, alreadyMigrated early-exit, [await] confirmation checkpoints, and error-recovery feedback loops ('Re-print summary with corrections and ask again until confirmed', 'Repeat until the developer confirms. Do NOT restart the entire flow'). For a destructive batch migration it also provides a rollback story (git branch, 'git checkout main to abandon'), matching the anchor for explicit validation steps plus feedback loops. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | References are clearly signaled and one level deep (a Supporting Files section plus inline ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR} paths), but scored against the actual bundle they don't resolve: none of the ten referenced agents/*.md or shared/*.md files exist in the bundle, while the one bundled file, references/spectrum-s2-upgrade.md, is never linked from SKILL.md and is therefore unreachable. Long inline sections (the ~40-line metadata derivation rules, the doc-scan-only protocol) also belong in the shared/ files the skill already envisages. This fits 'some structure but could be better organized' rather than the well-placed anchor at 4. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |