Content
88%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
An exceptionally operational orchestration skill: concrete schemas, commands, and exact strings; explicit validation gates, bounded retries, and batch-stop feedback loops; and a well-signaled on-demand reference layer. The main defects are a dangling reference to a nonexistent "orchestration-details.md" at the top of the body, near-verbatim duplication of the keyword-expansion list between the body and semantic-clustering.md, and some marketing-flavored padding in the differentiation section.
Suggestions
Fix the dangling reference: "Read the main reference `orchestration-details.md`" names a file absent from references/ — either add the file to the bundle or repoint the instruction at one of the three existing references (likely execution-workflow.md), since this pointer sits on the critical pre-execution path.
Deduplicate Plan Phase Step 1: replace the five inlined keyword-expansion bullets with a one-line pointer to references/semantic-clustering.md ("expand the seed per the four-step process in semantic-clustering.md"), keeping the body's 30-to-50 phrase target as the only local constraint.
Trim the Differentiation section: drop the "general contractor" closing line and compress the five-row table to the rows that affect routing decisions (blog-strategy, blog-write, blog-cannibalization), moving the rest to a reference if needed.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and operational almost everywhere — path canonicalization rules, XSS escaping specifics, a one-time cost-consent protocol — with essentially no explanation of concepts Claude already knows. It falls short of anchor 5 because Plan Phase Step 1's five-item keyword-expansion list duplicates references/semantic-clustering.md nearly verbatim, and the closing differentiation table carries marketing padding ("blog-cluster is the general contractor: it analyzes the topic, draws the data-driven plan, and builds the entire structure"). | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | The instruction-only guidance is fully concrete: a complete cluster-plan.json schema, an exact output-directory tree, exact commands ("blog_preflight.py --draft <post folder> --reset-iterations"), an exact marker format ("[INTERNAL-LINK: anchor -> filename.md]"), exact error strings ("No cluster plan found. Run `/blog cluster plan <seed-keyword>` first."), and a verbatim cost question to ask the user. This matches anchor 5's copy-paste-ready standard with common cases covered; it is not anchor 4 because there are no meaningful gaps in executable specificity. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Both phases have numbered, well-sequenced steps with explicit validation checkpoints throughout: user approval gates ("Ask for confirmation... Wait for explicit user approval. Do not auto-execute"), a quality-gate table with per-gate fail actions, a stop-the-batch feedback loop on gate failure with bounded retries ("at most 3 failed gate runs"), resume-on-next-invocation detection, and a scorecard link audit. As a batch operation it fully satisfies the batch-validation requirement, matching anchor 5 rather than anchor 4. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Structure is good: a dedicated "Key references (load on demand)" section plus per-phase "Reference:" signals, and all three named bundle files (semantic-clustering.md, cluster-architecture.md, execution-workflow.md) exist and are one level deep. It misses anchor 5 because "Read the main reference `orchestration-details.md`" names a file that does not exist in references/ (a dangling pointer on the critical pre-execution path), and because the Step 1 expansion list is inlined in the body where it duplicates the reference. It is still clearly above anchor 3, whose signature defects (buried, unclear references; large inlined reference content) are mostly absent. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 18 / 20 Passed |