Conciseness

Mostly lean — dense tables, no explanation of concepts Claude already knows, every section adds skill-specific content ("exit 0=confident, 10=abstain→AI", the abstain caller idiom). Minor trimmable redundancy: the mermaid flowchart restates the prose process, and Axis-B-mandatory is repeated in the "baseline failure" paragraph, the assertions section, and the Common Mistakes table.

Actionability

Fully executable guidance: a fixed output schema with a worked findings row and exact YAML block, a real runnable promptfoo template (verified present at references/promptfoo-template.yaml), bats test examples, and the concrete verification command "run `promptfoo eval -c determinism.promptfooconfig.yaml`" with the failure-recovery instruction.

Workflow Clarity

The process is explicitly sequenced (Parse → Read → Scan both axes → classify → generate assertions → emit fixed-schema report → ROI rank → write config → run config) with an explicit validation checkpoint and feedback loop: "If a test fails, fix the assertion (or the underlying Axis B fix) until all pass, then report ROI." The Common Mistakes table doubles as a checklist for failure modes.

Progressive Disclosure

The body is an overview that clearly signals one-level-deep references — "Full catalog (9 patterns + severity/effort rubric + bats template): [references/pattern-catalog.md]" and "The `determinism.promptfooconfig.yaml` template lives in [references/promptfoo-template.yaml]" — and both files exist in the bundle and contain exactly the promised content, with the seven most common patterns summarized inline for quick use.

Specificity

Multiple concrete actions are named: "auditing an existing agent skill (SKILL.md) to find where it leans on LLM judgment", "emit runnable promptfoo assertions", "offloading AI steps to code", and "constraining AI output format" — comprehensive coverage of what the skill does and produces. Written in third-person imperative voice with no fluff or buzzwords.

Completeness

Both "what" (audit a skill to find non-deterministic steps and emit runnable promptfoo assertions, with the two covered axes named) and "when" (an explicit "Use when auditing an existing agent skill" clause plus a "Triggers for" list with concrete phrases) are clearly and explicitly answered.

Trigger Term Quality

Explicit natural trigger phrases are quoted verbatim: "/determinize-skill PATH", "make this skill more deterministic", "audit a skill for determinism", "where can this skill be deterministic" — covering the command form plus multiple phrasings a user would naturally say.

Distinctiveness Conflict Risk

A clear niche — determinism auditing of agent skills with promptfoo assertions — with distinct trigger terms unlikely to fire for other skills; nothing generic that would overlap with general refactoring or testing skills.