Content
71%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body delivers a clear, actionable review procedure with concrete git commands and a defined finding format, appropriately self-contained for its size. Its main weakness is prose that references undefined external obligations ("review-ledger", "copied wrapper") which reads as leftover context from another environment and costs clarity.
Suggestions
Remove or rewrite the meta-commentary in the intro ("this copied wrapper does not prove that a built-in review, effort control or paid review mode is available") so the skill reads as instructions for this environment, not notes about its provenance.
Replace the undefined obligation reference ("Project review-ledger, independence, provider and publication requirements remain binding") with either the concrete requirements themselves or a pointer to where they are defined.
Add the explicit git command for the pinned base/HEAD comparison in step 3 (e.g., `git diff <base>..<HEAD>`) to make the branch-review path as executable as the working-diff path.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly efficient but includes unnecessary or confusing material: "this copied wrapper does not prove that a built-in review, effort control or paid review mode is available" is meta-commentary about the skill's provenance, and "Project review-ledger, independence, provider and publication requirements remain binding" references obligations never defined here. This matches the 3 anchor (mostly efficient, some unnecessary explanation) rather than the 4 anchor's "minor instances that could be trimmed", since these sentences cost real comprehension, not just tokens. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, executable commands are given (`git status --short`, `git diff`, `git diff --staged`, explicit reads for untracked files) plus a specific finding format ("`file:line`, a one-sentence defect statement, and a concrete failure scenario") and effort-to-breadth mapping. Minor gaps keep it below fully copy-paste-ready: the pinned base/HEAD comparison is described ("a comparison of the pinned base/HEAD commits") without the actual command, and "check the current host's command/skill inventory" lacks a concrete mechanism. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clear three-step sequence (establish scope, use supported tooling, local fallback with recursion guard) with most checkpoints present: drift check before reporting, explicit untracked-file handling, ranked findings, and the "Never invent findings" guard. This is a read-only review skill, so the destructive/batch validation cap does not apply; it sits at the 4 anchor (clear sequence, most checkpoints) rather than 5 because finding-verification feedback loops are only implicit. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | This is a single-file skill under 50 lines with no references/, scripts/, or assets/ directories and no need for external files; the short body is well-organized into a numbered procedure with bold step labels and clear navigation. Per the simple-skill guidance, that merits a 5 — nothing is inlined that belongs in a separate file. | 5 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |