Content
85%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A highly actionable, well-sequenced complex workflow skill with excellent bundle navigation and executable commands at every step. Its main weakness is token efficiency: the preview/confirmation policy and proxy-rendering rules are repeated across several sections and could be consolidated.
Suggestions
Consolidate the preview-before-export and confirmation-gating rules (currently restated in the intro, 第 1 步, 放手模式, 第 3 步, 第 6 步, and 底线 1) into one canonical section, leaving step-specific sections with only a short pointer.
Deduplicate the proxy-MP4 guidance: 「不默认生成代理 MP4 或整片样片」 and 「不默认渲染低清代理或 MP4 小样」 appear in 第 4 步 and 第 6 步 — state the rule once and reference it.
Tighten the long prose paragraphs in 第 1 步 and 第 3 步 into the existing table/bullet format used elsewhere; several sentences restate the 'confirm before proceeding' principle with only slight variation.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and mostly operational, but the preview/confirmation gating is restated repeatedly — 「停下来等用户确认,再写 brief」(第 1 步), 「真的等用户回复」(第 3 步), 「只有用户点击『导出视频』…才进入下一步」(第 6 步), and again in 底线 1 — and 「不默认渲染低清代理或 MP4 小样」 appears in both 第 4 步 and 第 6 步. Consolidating these into one canonical confirmation section would trim meaningful tokens without losing clarity. Not 4: the repetition goes beyond minor instances that could be trimmed; not 2 because the text never explains generic concepts and nearly every paragraph carries skill-specific decisions. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Fully executable commands cover every stage: 「sh <skill>/scripts/scaffold.sh <slug> [--audio synth|tone|layer|file|none]」, 「node <skill>/scripts/inspect.mjs qa <slug>/out/final.mp4 --out <slug>/qa/final --expect-size 1920x1080 --expect-fps 30 --expect-duration 16 --audio required」, plus a concrete YAML brief template, an audio-engine selection table, and hard rules with real syntax like 「revealOn(拍点, 转场时长, 揭开点)」 and 「[[b(36), DUR]]」. Copy-paste ready and covering the common cases. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | An 8-step workflow with explicit user-confirmation checkpoints (🛑 等用户确认 at steps 1, 3, and 6), programmatic validation gates — 「跑确定性检查 render.mjs <slug> --determinism,不通过就先修」 and 「只要有一项 FAIL,退出码就是 1,必须修好」 — and feedback loops (「修完只重渲有问题的那一段,再出整片」). Sequencing, checkpoints, and error recovery are all explicit. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The 「参考文件(按需读)」 table maps each of the 12 reference files to exactly when to read it, with targeted guidance like 「只读对应的那一节」 and 「先看 references/styles/INDEX.md,再只读选中的 1–2 个风格文件」. Every referenced path (including styles/INDEX.md, _template.md, and all 43 style files) exists in the bundle, references are one level deep and clearly signaled, and the SKILL.md body stays an operational overview while detail lives in the bundle. | 5 / 5 |
Total | 18 / 20 Passed |