Content
73%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured, highly actionable policy skill with an explicit sequenced workflow, validation feedback loop, and a real, well-placed one-level reference and audit script. Its weaknesses are cross-section rule repetition that inflates token cost and a SKILL.md that carries the entire policy rather than splitting repo-placement detail into the existing reference.
Suggestions
Consolidate repeated rules: state the single-owner, junk-path, and no-single-caller-abstraction rules once in the Creation Gate, and remove their restatements in Non-Negotiable Outcomes, Reuse Decision, and Completion Standard.
Move the Frontend Rules and Server placement tables into references/repository-boundaries.md (which already contains a placement map) and keep SKILL.md to the workflow, gates, and a pointer to that reference.
Include the exact typecheck/test commands per verification category (e.g., the owning package's script names) so the Verification By Risk section is copy-paste executable like the audit command.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense, imperative, and never explains concepts Claude already knows — but it restates the same rules multiple times: single-owner/one-source-of-truth appears in Non-Negotiable Outcomes, Creation Gate, Server, and Completion Standard; junk/dead paths ('new', 'old', 'v2', abandoned files) appear in three sections; 'do not add a generic abstraction for one caller' appears in both Creation Gate and Reuse Decision. Mostly efficient, but it could be tightened by consolidating these repetitions. Not a 4 because the redundancy is more than minor (the Non-Negotiable Outcomes section largely previews later sections); not a 2 because there is no padded explanation or filler. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Mostly executable guidance: concrete search targets ('Search... with `rg`' over named directories like `apps/app/src/components/ui`, `apps/server/src`, `packages/types`), an exact audit command ('node .codex/skills/ipollowork-maintainable-code/scripts/audit-changes.mjs'), a situation→action decision table, and concrete checks like 'git diff --check'. Not a 5 because key verification steps name the activity ('run the owning package typecheck and focused tests') without the actual commands, and several gates remain policy statements rather than executable steps. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The 'Required Workflow' is a clearly sequenced 9-step process with explicit validation checkpoints and a feedback loop — step 8 runs package checks plus the audit script, step 9 says 'Resolve every error. Fix warnings or give a concrete... reason' — supplemented by a risk-based verification matrix and a completion checklist. This matches the 5 anchor (explicit validation, error-recovery loop, checklist) rather than the 4 anchor, which requires a validation gap. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Good structure: the single reference ('Read references/repository-boundaries.md before adding a file, directory, dependency...') is well-signaled at the exact decision point, is one level deep, and is a real, substantive bundle file; the audit script is likewise real. Not a 5 because SKILL.md is the full policy document (~125 lines) rather than an overview — the Frontend Rules and Server/Generated Files placement rules largely duplicate the reference's placement map and could be split out; not a 3 because what references exist are clearly signaled and organized. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |