Content
46%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body has the right shape for a foundation-routing skill — explicit scope, audience, load/not-load triggers, and a loading order — and includes a few concrete commands and paths. Its two real defects are repetition of the same routing message across five sections and, more seriously, that its entire disclosure strategy rests on two companion files that are neither named by path nor actually shipped in the bundle, making the core instructions unexecutable.
Suggestions
Name the companions with explicit resolvable paths (e.g. "see references/capabilities.md" / "references/tasks.md") and ship those files in the bundle — the Loading order, Instructions, and 'What this skill provides' sections all point at 'the capabilities companion' and 'the tasks companion' with no path, and no such files exist in the bundle.
Collapse the repeated routing into a single section: the capabilities-vs-tasks split, the doca-setup handoff, and the doc-lookup handoff are each restated in Instructions, When to load, What this skill provides, Loading order, and Related skills; merging them would cut roughly a third of the body.
Make each Loading order step executable on its own — include the exact `pkg-config --modversion doca-common` install-verification checkpoint inline and state what the agent should do if a companion file or an expected /opt/mellanox/doca path is missing.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is honest that it is a "thin loader" and mostly avoids explaining general concepts, but the routing message is repeated across "Instructions", "When to load this skill", "What this skill provides", "Loading order", and "Related skills" — e.g. the two-tier log model, the doca-setup handoff, and the capabilities-vs-tasks split each appear three or more times, and the "Example questions this skill answers well" section runs ~45 lines of italicized prose that could be halved. It is mostly efficient domain signal but could be tightened by roughly a third; it does not reach anchor 2's 'several unnecessary explanations or padded sections' since no section is content-free. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | There are some genuinely concrete anchors — `pkg-config --modversion doca-common`, `/opt/mellanox/doca/samples/<library>/<sample>/*_main.c`, the full create→progress→stop verb chain, and named sibling-skill paths like `doca-setup/SKILL.md` — but the skill's primary instructed actions ("Open the tasks companion", "see the capabilities companion") name no file path, and no such files exist anywhere in the bundle (no references/, scripts/, or assets/ directories). The central instruction is therefore not executable as written, which is exactly the anchor-3 'missing key details' case rather than anchor 4's 'minor gaps'. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | "Loading order" gives a real 3-step sequence with an explicit question-type decision rule (what-does-Common-express → capabilities; do/configure/build/debug → tasks) and a precondition check (route to doca-setup if DOCA is not installed), so a coherent sequence is present. But the steps' destinations are unresolvable — the two companions have no paths and no files behind them — leaving the sequence present with key checkpoints implicit, which fits anchor 3 better than anchor 4's fully concrete per-step commands. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The thin-loader architecture is the right idea and the references are prominently signaled rather than buried, but scored against the actual bundle the disclosure structure is broken: the body's substantive material is promised to "two companion files" that are never given a path, and the bundle ships no references/, scripts/, or assets/ at all. An agent following the Loading order dead-ends immediately, which lands below the anchor-3 'references present but not clearly signaled' (they are signaled) and matches anchor 2's practical failure — the structure that clearly belongs in separate files is neither named nor present. | 2 / 5 |
Total | 11 / 20 Passed |