Content
75%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured, actionable instruction-only skill with a clear six-step workflow, named tool calls, and a genuine one-level-deep template reference. It falls short of top marks due to elided parameters in artifact calls, the absence of an explicit validate/retry loop in the reconciliation step, and inline taxonomy/routing content that could be offloaded to references.
Suggestions
Replace elided parameters in artifact calls (e.g., 'artifact.attach_baseline(...)') with the required arguments or one minimal worked example so the guidance is copy-paste ready.
Add an explicit validation checkpoint in the trust-rank/reconcile step (e.g., what to do when verification of an existing baseline fails: re-verify, downgrade trust level, or route to 'baseline') to close the missing feedback loop.
Move the trust-level taxonomy and companion-skill routing tables into a reference file and link 'references/state-audit-template.md' markdown-style, trimming the main body's length.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is directive-dense with no teaching of known concepts, and system-specific details (tool cadence, startup_contract fields) earn their tokens. A few emphasis/explanatory lines ('This skill exists because many quests do not start from a clean slate', 'The point is to reuse prior route knowledge...') could be trimmed. Not score 5 because of those minor instances; not score 3 because padding is rare and the document largely assumes Claude's competence. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, specific guidance throughout: exact tool calls ('memory.list_recent(scope=\'quest\', limit=5)', 'artifact.record(payload={\'kind\': \'decision\', ...})'), named files to inspect ('brief.md', 'plan.md', 'artifacts/', 'baselines/'), and a real template at 'references/state-audit-template.md'. Not score 5 because most artifact calls use elided parameters ('artifact.attach_baseline(...)') rather than copy-paste-ready signatures; not score 3 because guidance is mostly executable with only minor gaps. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clear six-step numbered sequence (read startup intent, retrieve memory, inventory, trust-rank/reconcile, choose next anchor, report/hand off) with an explicit insufficiency guard ('If the evidence is insufficient for a durable backfill, record that insufficiency explicitly instead of inventing a cleaned-up history') and non-negotiable rules acting as checkpoints. Not score 5 because there is no explicit validate-then-retry loop when a trust check or reconciliation fails; not score 3 because the sequence is complete with most checkpoints present and no destructive batch operation lacking validation. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Good section structure with one real, one-level-deep bundle reference ('references/state-audit-template.md') that exists on disk and is clearly signaled at point of use. Not score 5 because the reference is not linked markdown-style and sizable inline material (trust-level taxonomy, companion-skill routing, primary truth sources) could live in reference files to slim the ~280-line body; not score 3 because structure is clear and the reference is not buried. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |