Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The content is strongly actionable — exact commands, a strict per-task format with correct/incorrect examples, and a well-sequenced workflow ending in a validation checklist. Its weaknesses are the near-verbatim duplication of the extension-hook protocol across the pre- and post-execution sections and the absence of any bundle/reference structure, both fixable by extracting the hook rules into a shared reference file.
Suggestions
Extract the duplicated extension-hook protocol (enabled filtering, condition handling, dot-to-hyphen conversion, YAML error reporting, output templates) into a shared reference file (e.g. references/hooks.md) and have both Pre-Execution and Post-Execution sections point to it, removing ~30 duplicated lines.
Add a fallback for missing required inputs: state what to do if plan.md or spec.md is absent under FEATURE_DIR or if setup-tasks.sh fails or emits no FEATURE_DIR.
Show the expected shape of TASKS_TEMPLATE_CONTENT (or point to the template file) so the 'Generate tasks.md' step is copy-paste executable rather than dependent on unseen content.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and operational with no padding over concepts Claude already knows, but the extension-hook protocol (enabled filtering, condition handling, dot-to-hyphen replacement, YAML parse-error handling, output templates) is repeated nearly verbatim in both "Pre-Execution Checks" and "Mandatory Post-Execution Hooks" — roughly 30 duplicated lines that could be collapsed to a single shared rule. That is more than the 'minor instances' of a 4, but far from the padded over-explanation of a 2. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is highly executable: the exact command ".specify/scripts/bash/setup-tasks.sh --json" with parsed JSON fields, a strict checklist format "- [ ] [TaskID] [P?] [Story?] Description with file path" with concrete correct and wrong examples, and shell escape syntax for quotes. Not 5 because hook invocation remains partly abstract ("the invocation may differ from the literal {command} id") and template filling depends on TASKS_TEMPLATE_CONTENT whose shape is not shown. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Clear sequence: pre-execution hooks → setup script → load documents → task generation rules → generate tasks.md → post-execution hooks → completion report, ending in a "Done When" checklist. Validation checkpoints exist ("Validate task completeness", "Format validation: Confirm ALL tasks follow the checklist format") plus YAML-error feedback handling. Not 5 because there are minor gaps: no fallback if a required plan.md or spec.md is missing, and no handling if the setup script itself fails. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | No bundle files exist (no references/, scripts/, or assets/), so everything lives inline in a ~200-line SKILL.md. Section structure is good, but the ~60 lines of hook-dispatch machinery — duplicated across two sections — clearly belongs in a shared reference file, matching "content that should be separate is inline". It is better organized than a monolithic wall of text (2), but not the well-split structure of a 4. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |