Content
96%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
An exceptionally tight procedural skill: concrete commands, exact file formats, a numbered workflow with genuine red/green validation gates, user-approval checkpoints, and thoughtful gotchas (model pinning for plugin subagents, tmp-folder lifetime). The only structural gap is that all operational detail lives in SKILL.md itself with no references, which is defensible for a workflow this size but leaves the longest tables (replay levels, lesson kinds) inlined in the overview.
Suggestions
Consider moving the step-3 replay-level table and the lesson-kind table into a references/ file (e.g., references/replay-levels.md) so SKILL.md stays a lean overview and the detail loads only when routing lessons.
The step-2 routing decision tree could be extracted alongside the replay table, keeping the seven-step skeleton and pass conditions in the main body.
If the file grows further (the skill itself warns at 180 lines for make-it-right), apply its own prune guidance to itself: the Gotchas section is a natural candidate for a one-level-deep reference.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is lean and dense: no concept explanations, no preamble, no padding. Every line carries an instruction, an exact path, a command, or a decision rule (e.g., "Can't make it fail in three tries → drop the lesson and say why"). It fully assumes Claude's competence. | 5 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is concrete and executable throughout: exact commands ("claude -p --model <id>", "git log --grep '^Lesson:' <prune>..HEAD"), exact file paths and row formats ("date | target file | repo | base sha | run folder | pass condition"), a replay table mapping each target to its level, and explicit pass conditions. Absence of full code is fine for an orchestration skill; the guidance is copy-paste ready where deterministic. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Seven explicitly numbered steps with strong validation checkpoints and feedback loops: red must fail for the claimed reason with a three-try drop rule and "fix the setup, never the pass condition"; green requires 2-of-3 reruns plus regression against every saved case targeting the same file ("A case that breaks blocks the edit"); edits apply only on user approval. This exceeds the top anchor. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Well-organized single-file structure with clear section headers, tables, and a Gotchas section, and no wasted cross-references — but there is no progressive-disclosure structure at all: at ~146 lines everything (replay-level table, lesson-kind table, routing rules, gotchas) is inlined in SKILL.md, and the rubric's allowance for scoring 5 without external references applies only to skills under 50 lines. It fits anchor 4 (good structure, minor organization gaps) rather than anchor 5, which expects content appropriately split across well-signaled references. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 19 / 20 Passed |