Content
75%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A notably lean, dense instructional skill with a clear five-step sequence and up-front reference pointers. Its weakest point is actionability: several steps remain abstract and no concrete example (e.g., a sample comparison-record entry or an exemplar 'move') grounds the more complex requirements. Reference links also point outside the bundle, which weakens navigation verifiability.
Suggestions
Add a short worked example of one 'compact comparison record' entry showing the revised location, original vs. revised passage, study evidence, and exemplar page/paragraph, so step 4 is directly executable.
Include one brief example of a useful move lifted from an exemplar (one or two lines) and how it is matched to the study's evidence, to make steps 2–3 concrete instead of abstract.
Make the verification checkpoints explicit loops (e.g., 'if the rewritten passage does not make the claimed transition, revise and re-check before proceeding') in steps 2 and 5, and verify that the ../../skill/references/ links resolve from the installed skill location.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is ~10 lines with zero padding: it never explains concepts Claude already knows (no 'what a Discussion section is'), and every clause is instructional ('Open the actual sources. Work in a new revision when replacing a substantial draft.'). This matches 'lean and efficient; assumes Claude's competence; every token earns its place'; it is not the level-4 case because there are no instances of over-explanation to trim. | 5 / 5 |
Actionability | Some steps are genuinely concrete — step 4 specifies the comparison record's fields ('revised location, actual original and revised passages, study evidence, and exemplar version and page/paragraph') — but steps 1–3 lean abstract ('Build the paper's own argument around its scientific question... warranted contribution', 'integrate contrary evidence') and there are no examples, templates, or sample passages showing what a transferred 'move' or a comparison-record entry looks like. This fits 'some concrete guidance but incomplete; missing key details', below the mostly-executable level-4 anchor and above the high-level-hints anchor at 2. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The five numbered steps form a coherent sequence (identify materials → read exemplars → write → record comparisons → full-rewrite protocol) with embedded checkpoints like 'Check whether the rewritten passage actually makes the claimed transition' and 'inspect the affected manuscript or rendered pages'. It falls short of the level-5 anchor because the checkpoints are not framed as explicit validate→fix→retry loops or checklists, but it exceeds level 3 since verification is stated rather than absent. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is short and points to exactly two one-level-deep reference files, clearly signaled up front ('Begin with [direct scientific writing](...) and [evidence-led writing...](...)'). However, those links and '../EDITION-MANAGEMENT.md' use relative paths pointing outside the skill bundle (../../skill/references/), which do not resolve within the provided bundle, and the body has no section headers; these minor organization and navigation gaps place it at 'good structure; references mostly clear' rather than the fully well-signaled, easily navigable level-5 anchor. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |