Conciseness

Lean, well-organized prose that assumes Claude's competence; every line adds specific guidance about scoping, messaging, and verifying commits with no padding or basic-Git explanations.

Actionability

Provides concrete, executable guidance (inspect staged/unstaged/untracked, split vs. preserve, verify content/exclusion/untouched state, return hash+message+scope) with minor gaps for an instruction-only skill lacking exact commands.

Workflow Clarity

Clear sequenced sections with an explicit verification checkpoint ("Verify the resulting commit contains every intended change, excludes unrelated changes, and leaves the remaining worktree state untouched") and a stop-and-ask guardrail, though error-recovery feedback loops are only implicit.

Progressive Disclosure

Under 50 lines with well-organized sections (Scope, Message, Commit and verify) and no external references needed, matching the simple-skill exception for progressive disclosure.

Specificity

Names the Git-commit domain and the concrete action "Creates Git commits for completed work" but offers only that one action, with no enumeration of broader capabilities, matching the 1-2 concrete actions anchor.

Completeness

Explicitly states what it does (creates Git commits for completed work) and gives concrete "when" trigger phrases including user requests, workflow handoffs, and skill invocation.

Trigger Term Quality

Covers natural user phrasings ("committing changes", "asks to commit the work") plus the invocation token $prp-commit, giving good keyword coverage though a few common synonyms like "save" or "checkpoint" are absent.

Distinctiveness Conflict Risk

Clear niche tied to PRP-workflow commits with distinct triggers and an explicit $prp-commit invocation token, minimizing overlap with other skills.