Content
70%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body delivers exceptionally actionable, well-sequenced guidance with real validation gates and feedback loops — model execution clarity. Its weaknesses are repetition (the verify-gate contract is explained five times) and the absence of any progressive disclosure: everything, including deep policy specs and basic execution hygiene, lives in one large file.
Suggestions
State the omc ralph verify contract (flags, exit codes, timeout handling, baseline semantics) once — in <Precondition_Feedback_Gate> — and have Steps 1f, 4b, and 7.6 reference it instead of restating it, cutting substantial tokens.
Move the PRD_Criterion_Amendments ledger spec, the stale-state reconciliation JSON example, and the parallel-session caveats into one-level-deep reference files under references/ and link them clearly, keeping SKILL.md as the loop overview.
Drop or trim the <Advanced> background/foreground execution rules and other reminders of basics Claude already knows; keep only the skill-specific policy.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~370-line body restates the verify-gate semantics in five places (<Precondition_Feedback_Gate>, Step 1f, Step 4b, Step 7.6, Final Checklist), repeats the "polite-stop anti-pattern / do not stop after approval" warning in both Step 7 and Escalation_And_Stop_Conditions, and includes an <Advanced> section explaining background-vs-foreground execution basics ("Package installation... run in background", "Quick status checks... foreground") that Claude already knows. Not 3 because these are several distinct padded/redundant sections rather than minor tightening opportunities; not 1 because most of the policy content is genuine non-obvious domain knowledge rather than generic concept explanation. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is fully executable: exact commands with flags ("omc ralph verify --write-baseline --session <sessionId>", "omc ralph closeout --deslop completed"), concrete state paths (.omc/state/sessions/{sessionId}/prd.json, feedback-baseline.json), a JSON reconciliation schema, programmatic API signatures (amendCriterion/supersedeCriterion), and complete worked examples for Task() delegation and criterion amendment. Exit-code semantics (0 = pass, 1 = new failures) make the gates machine-checkable. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Ten explicitly sequenced steps with lettered sub-steps, mandatory validation gates at story verification (Step 4), post-deslop regression (Step 7.6), and closeout, plus explicit feedback loops: exit-1 failures are fixed and re-verified, reviewer rejection (Step 9) loops back to fixing and re-marking, and a Final Checklist enforces terminal state. Not 4 because validation checkpoints are not merely present but explicit and exit-code driven throughout. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Sections are clearly labeled (XML-style tags, numbered steps), but this is a single monolithic ~370-line file: detailed policy blocks (the criterion-amendment ledger spec, stale-state reconciliation JSON, parallel-session caveats, background-execution rules) are inlined where reference files would fit, and mentions of docs/shared/agent-tiers.md, docs/company-context-interface.md, and docs/REFERENCE.md are buried mid-paragraph rather than clearly signaled navigation — and no references/ bundle exists. Not 2 because the internal structure is strong and navigation within the file is possible; not 4 because several substantial blocks clearly belong in one-level-deep reference files. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |