Conciseness

The body is dense with non-obvious operational policy, but has noticeable duplication: the SI confirmation gate appears both in the top blockquote and again in 'Download Intake and First-Run Configuration' with the same Chinese question, the Web of Science fallback URL is stated twice, and node-fallback/install-location paths repeat across sections. This fits the 'mostly efficient but could be tightened' anchor rather than the 'minor instances' of 4.

Actionability

Copy-paste-ready commands cover the common cases (batch_download.mjs examples for topic/DOI/title/Chinese-title/pdf-url, full configure_school.py and configure_credentials.py command sets, a PowerShell CDP check block), matching the 'mostly executable; minor gaps' anchor. Not 5 because 'src/wizard.py' and 'requirements.txt' are referenced in Preconditions but absent from the bundle.

Workflow Clarity

The multi-step process is clearly sequenced with an enforced validation gate ('returns si_confirmation_required and does not create the output directory'), an 8-item preconditions checklist, bounded verification attempts, and typed failure statuses that form explicit feedback loops (verification_auto_failed to user handoff, api_fallback_confirmation_required, retry_after_user_verification). This matches the anchor with validation steps, error recovery, and checklists.

Progressive Disclosure

Two real, clearly signaled, one-level-deep reference files with explicit load conditions ('Load ... when legitimate OA and applicable publisher-API routes are exhausted...'), matching the 'good structure; minor organization gaps' anchor. Not 5 because the 353-line body inlines detail (the Springer service credential matrix, extended status semantics) that belongs in references despite the stated intent to 'keep this router compact'.

Specificity

Enumerates six concrete capability areas ('lawful academic full text', 'CNKI institutional access', 'English OA retrieval', 'publisher API access', 'institutional browser fallback', 'supporting information downloads'), matching the 'several specific actions; minor gaps' anchor. Not 5 because capabilities like batch downloading, output formats, and manifests are unstated, and actions are phrased as user needs rather than what the skill does.

Completeness

An explicit 'Use when...' clause covers when clearly, and what is conveyed through the enumerated deliverables ('full text', 'downloads'), fitting the 'both what and when; when could be more explicit' anchor inverted. Not 5 because the what is only implied by the when-clause and never stated with the skill's own action verbs.

Trigger Term Quality

Good natural keyword coverage ('CNKI', 'full text', 'supporting information', 'OA', 'publisher API') that users in this domain would say, matching the 'good keyword coverage; a few natural terms missing' anchor. Not 5 because common synonyms like 'paper', 'article', 'PDF', and 'open access' spelled out are missing.

Distinctiveness Conflict Risk

'CNKI institutional access' and 'supporting information downloads' are highly distinctive triggers, while 'English OA retrieval' has minor overlap risk with generic literature-search skills, matching the 'mostly distinct; minor overlap risk' anchor. Not 5 because a general open-access paper-finding skill could trigger on the OA phrase.