Content
70%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a well-gated auditor workflow with explicit checkpoints, veto conditions, and persistence validation, and it is commendably free of padding. Its weaknesses are executability and bundling: the referenced runbooks, scorer, and validator script are absent from this bundle, so the detailed procedure cannot actually be followed here, and the reference sections overlap and point mostly outside the bundle.
Suggestions
Bundle or inline the execution-critical references (auditor-runbook.md, scoring-semantics.md, send-benchmark.md, runtime-invocation.md, measurement-protocol.md) — the ../../../references/ paths do not resolve in a standalone install where only references/auditor-runtime.md is present.
Ship scripts/validate-audit-artifact.py in the bundle; it is invoked by name with a --relative-path flag but no scripts/ directory exists.
Deduplicate the routing guidance (the Skill Contract prose line vs the Next Best Skill section) and resolve the §2/§3/§5 section numbering gap (no §1 or §4 appears in the body) or replace it with plain descriptive headers.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and lean — tables, terse bullets, no explanations of concepts Claude already knows (DMARC, MPP, and consent law are used, not taught). Not level 5 because routing guidance is stated twice ("Use `deliverability-qa` to repair authentication..." in Skill Contract and again as Next Best Skill links), and a few compressed jargon sentences ("Open rate is MPP-sensitive proxy evidence; direct action and the program's declared outcome truth set carry the outcome read") must be re-read; not level 3 because there is no padding anywhere. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | There is concrete structure — exact env-var resolution ("AARON_SKILLS_ROOT=\"${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT:-$(git rev-parse --show-toplevel 2>/dev/null || true)}\""), named veto IDs with conditions, exact scorer states (`score_state: NOT_SCORED`), the artifact path pattern `memory/audits/email/YYYY-MM-DD-<topic>.md`, and an invocation of `validate-audit-artifact.py --relative-path` — but the execution machinery is incomplete in this bundle: 4 of 5 Runtime Reads (`../../../references/auditor-runbook.md`, `scoring-semantics.md`, `send-benchmark.md`, `runtime-invocation.md`) and the validator script are not present, so an agent in this standalone context cannot fully execute the audit. This lands on the level-3 anchor (concrete guidance but incomplete, missing key details) rather than level 4, whose "minor gaps" these are not. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The sequence is explicit and well-gated: declare profile → resolve runtime → freeze and reconcile evidence → score all 20 criteria → verify the four vetoes → run typed scorer → report with the exact typed header → validation checkpoints → persistence. It includes an explicit checklist (Validation Checkpoints), a validate→persist-once→revalidate feedback loop in Persistence, and error recovery when the scorer is unavailable (return `NOT_SCORED/UNDECIDED`), matching the level-5 anchor rather than level 4's "most checkpoints". | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | In-body structure is good (clear sections, details conceptually pushed to reference files, one level deep), but scored against the actual bundle most references dangle: only `references/auditor-runtime.md` exists, while the Runtime Reads and Reference Materials sections point at five `../../../references/*.md` files and the Next Best Skill section points at sibling SKILL.md files that are not in this bundle. Two overlapping reference lists (Runtime Reads vs Reference Materials, which additionally lists a `measurement-protocol.md` not in Runtime Reads) further muddy navigation. This fits the level-3 anchor (some structure, references present but organization is imperfect) rather than level 4's "most content is appropriately placed". | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |