Content
56%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is dense, accurate, and largely actionable, with a clear decision-order sequence and concrete configuration commands. Its dominant weakness is token efficiency: ~700 lines of implementation edge-case rules are inlined into SKILL.md rather than split into reference files. Progressive disclosure suffers further because the referenced detail files do not exist in the bundle.
Suggestions
Move the exhaustive rule enumerations (prior-search credit matching rules, public-surface language lists, comment/whitespace triviality rules) into a references/ file and keep a decision-relevant summary in SKILL.md.
Ship the cited files (docs/gateguard/change-profile.md, docs/gateguard/question-effectiveness.md, scripts/gateguard-report.js) in the bundle or remove/replace the citations, since every deferred-to path currently dangles.
Add the actual hooks.json snippet to Quick Start Option A and an explicit verification step (e.g. confirm the hook fires via GATEGUARD_METRICS) to close the workflow gap.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~700-line body exhaustively enumerates implementation edge cases (the prior-search credit section alone spans ~120 lines of rules like "a tool-use id that appears more than once never counts" and "commands containing `$( )`, backticks... longer than 8192 characters, never credit") that belong in reference docs. It is noticeably verbose with padded rule detail, though it does not explain concepts Claude already knows, so it stays above the severely-padded anchor. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Provides mostly executable guidance: a concrete env-var table with defaults, the report command "node scripts/gateguard-report.js --dir /path/to/state --json", a copy-paste JSON env block, and a numbered order-of-checks. Minor gaps remain — Option A says "Enable it via hooks.json" without showing the hooks.json snippet, and the pip/Option B flow's relationship to the ECC hook is left implicit. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The gate's decision flow is an explicit ordered sequence ("the first rule that applies wins: 1. Exempt... 9. Deny") with batch handling guidance ("Send dependent edits... sequentially, not in a parallel batch") and a retry loop ("present the facts, retry the denied edit, and re-read the file"). The destructive/batch validation cap does not bind since the skill configures a gate rather than performing destructive operations itself; what keeps it from 5 is the absence of an explicit verify-the-setup step in Quick Start. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Section headers and anchors make the document navigable, but the bundle contains no references/, scripts/, or assets/ directories, so cited paths ("docs/gateguard/change-profile.md", "docs/gateguard/question-effectiveness.md", "scripts/gateguard-report.js", "see the design notes for the full list") dangle, and large rule sets that belong in separate files are inlined. This matches the some-structure-but-inline-heavy anchor rather than the well-placed one, since navigation fails exactly where the body defers detail. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |