Content
67%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The process content itself is strong: a well-sequenced, human-gated workflow with concrete paths, file conventions, and a tight glossary that justifies its length. The critical defect is that the skill as shipped is broken at its own architecture — every sidecar carrying the real depth (definitions, dependency classification, card contract, interface-design method) is referenced but absent from the bundle, so progressive disclosure fails and the deferred detail in actionability is unrecoverable.
Suggestions
Ship the referenced sidecars (LANGUAGE.md, DEEPENING.md, PRESENTING.md, INTERFACE-DESIGN.md) in the bundle, or inline their essentials and stop pointing at files the skill does not carry — 0 of 6 referenced files currently exist next to SKILL.md.
State invariant §10 once (e.g., in the intro blockquote) and refer back to it by id from 'What this skill does not do' and Hand off; do the same for the glossary-usage rules, which currently appear in three places.
Add an explicit self-check before ending phase 2 (e.g., verify each card uses only glossary terms and cites any conflicting record id), so validation does not rest solely on the human.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~155-line body is dense and mostly earns its tokens — the glossary, deletion test, and scoping heuristics are kit-specific knowledge, not things Claude already knows — but there is repeated over-explanation: invariant §10 is stated three times (intro blockquote, "What this skill does not do", and Hand off), and glossary-usage rules appear in three places. That is a handful of trimmable spots rather than padding, fitting the 4 anchor ('efficient; minor instances of over-explanation') better than 3. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is mostly executable: exact artifact paths to read first (docs/domain-glossary.md, docs/adr/, constitution/local-engineering.md), a concrete temp-file convention ("$TMPDIR falling back to /tmp… <tmpdir>/architecture-review-<timestamp>"), a fixed card schema with an enumerated recommendation scale, and the exact closing question ("Which of these would you like to explore?"). It stops short of 5 because the payload behind several steps — "Full definitions in LANGUAGE.md", "DEEPENING.md is how to classify the dependencies", PRESENTING.md's card contract — is deferred to files that are not in the bundle, leaving key details missing at execution time. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clearly sequenced four-phase process (scope→explore, present candidates, grilling loop, hand off) with most checkpoints present: read decision records before proposing, spawn exploration in fresh context, stop after writing the report and ask the human to pick, route style-level findings to /design-brief, mark record conflicts on the card. It is not 5 because validation is delegated to the human rather than explicit self-check steps, and the report-writing step has no verification of its own; the destructive/batch cap does not apply since exploration is read-only and the report lands outside the repo. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body signals its references well and they are one level deep, but scored against the actual bundle structure every one is dangling: LANGUAGE.md, PRESENTING.md, DEEPENING.md, and INTERFACE-DESIGN.md are linked as ./-relative files and ../grill-with-docs/GLOSSARY-FORMAT.md and ADR-FORMAT.md as kit siblings, yet the bundle ships only SKILL.md — 0 of 6 referenced files exist. A dead link is worse than a buried one, so this lands below the 3 anchor ('references present but not clearly signaled'), matching the 2 anchor's structural failure. | 2 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |