Content
75%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-crafted instruction-only skill: concrete deliverable specs, real security engineering (per-sink escaping, CSP, secret redaction, prompt-injection distrust of diff content), and an explicit pre-save validation scan. The consistent weaknesses are minor — no literal commands for the merge-base resolution, sequence spread across sections instead of one procedure, a few trimmable rationale asides, and a referenced MICROWORLDS.md that is missing from the bundle.
Suggestions
Include the actual git commands for scope resolution (e.g., `git merge-base origin/<default> HEAD` then `git diff <merge-base>..HEAD`) so the targeting step is copy-paste executable rather than described.
Ship the referenced MICROWORLDS.md alongside SKILL.md (or inline its essential heuristics) — the body delegates the microworld catalog, honesty rules, and when-to-use guidance to a file that is not present in the bundle.
Consolidate the operating procedure into one ordered list (resolve change → explore background → write sections → apply format/escaping rules → pre-save scan → report path), making the pre-save scan an explicit pass/fail gate with a fix-and-rescan loop.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and instructional — scope resolution, section specs, format/security rules — with almost no padding of concepts Claude already knows. Minor over-explanation could be trimmed: the rationale asides ("a quiz whose right answer is always option B tests pattern-matching", "or the browser will collapse all newlines"), the Kleppmann style flourish, and the three-line provenance footer, which keeps it below the lean anchor 5 but above the noticeably-verbose anchors. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | For an instruction-only skill the guidance is highly concrete: literal "git fetch origin", a fully specified output path scheme with an example ($TMPDIR/YYYY-MM-DD-explanation-<slug>.html, slug charset), exact CSP directives, per-sink escaping rules, and a precise quiz spec (five questions, randomized correct-answer position, click feedback). It stops short of anchor 5's copy-paste readiness — the merge-base step says "find the merge-base" without the literal `git merge-base` command, and default-branch detection is delegated to a constitution file. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The flow — resolve the change, explore surrounding code for background, write the four sections, apply format rules, run the pre-save scan, report the path — is coherent and includes an explicit validation checkpoint ("Before saving the file, scan each code block in the HTML source and confirm its CSS includes white-space: pre or pre-wrap", extended to both sinks). It is not a 5: the sequence is distributed across sections rather than one ordered procedure, and there is no error-recovery loop for what to do when the pre-save scan fails; it is above anchor 3 because the checkpoint is explicit, not implicit. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Good in-file structure (Scope, Sections, Format, boundaries) with a single, well-signaled one-level reference: MICROWORLDS.md is pointed to with a precise description of what it carries ("catalog of world types, the when-to-use heuristics, and the honesty rules"). The gap keeping it from 5: that referenced file is not present in the skill bundle — no references/, scripts/, or assets/ directories exist and no MICROWORLDS.md sits alongside SKILL.md — so the sole external navigation point is a dead link, though it degrades gracefully since the micro-world feature is optional and conditional. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |