Content
48%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The core two-step PubMed-then-LLM workflow is well sequenced with status-based checkpoints and a valid one-level-deep reference, but the body is padded with boilerplate sections, references a script missing from the bundle, and is visibly truncated mid-instruction in the PDF helper section. Tightening the file and fixing the broken script reference would materially improve it.
Suggestions
Fix the bundle mismatch: either add scripts/baseline_extractor.py or rewrite Step 1 to use the existing extract_pdf.py / a real PubMed-check command.
Delete the generic 'Key Features', 'Dependencies', and 'Implementation Details' filler sections and repair the garbled first 'When to Use' bullet; they restate the description without adding guidance.
Complete the truncated 'PDF Text Extraction' section (it ends mid-sentence at 'before assessment:') and replace the dated cd '20260316/scientific-skills/...' path with the skill's own directory.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Several padded sections add no actionable information: 'When to Use' contains garbled restatements of the description ("when you need extracts clinical trial baseline data ... in a reproducible workflow"), 'Key Features' repeats the description verbatim, and 'Dependencies'/'Implementation Details' offer generic packaging boilerplate ("Reference guidance: references/ contains supporting rules, prompts, or checklists", "See ## Workflow above for related details"). This matches 'noticeably verbose; several unnecessary explanations or padded sections', though it stops short of the score-1 level of explaining concepts Claude already knows. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | There is concrete guidance — a subprocess call for the PubMed check with explicit status-based handling, a link to the extraction schema, and a specified JSON output format — but key pieces are incomplete: 'scripts/baseline_extractor.py' does not exist in the bundle (only extract_pdf.py), the Example Usage cds into a dated local path ('20260316/scientific-skills/...') that won't exist elsewhere, and the 'PDF Text Extraction' section is truncated mid-sentence ('before assessment:'). This lands on the 'some concrete guidance but incomplete ... missing key details' anchor rather than 4, whose code/commands should be mostly executable as written. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The hybrid workflow is clearly sequenced with an explicit validation checkpoint: Step 1 checks PubMed and branches on status ('If status is "success": Stop here ... If "not_found", "incomplete", or "error" ... Proceed to Step 2'), and Step 2 includes an anti-hallucination constraint ('If a field is not mentioned in the text, set it to null'). It falls short of 5 because there is no recovery loop for a failed extraction (e.g., retry or escalate) and the truncated helper section leaves the PDF path unfinished. No destructive/batch cap applies. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Scored against the actual bundle: references/extraction_schema.md exists, is one level deep, and is clearly signaled with a markdown link — good — but the body's primary script reference 'scripts/baseline_extractor.py' does not exist in scripts/ (which contains only extract_pdf.py), and generic boilerplate that belongs in no file at all is inlined in SKILL.md. A nonexistent referenced script plus inlined filler is more than the 'minor organization gaps' of 4, fitting 'some structure but could be better organized'. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 12 / 20 Passed |