Content
67%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured, safety-conscious instruction skill with concrete output contracts, a refusal mechanism, and a verifiable script reference. The main weaknesses are the duplicated type-recognition section inflating token cost, the absence of a worked output example, and the underspecified 'enrich' step in the workflow.
Suggestions
Merge 'Type Recognition Rules' into 'When to Use' (or reduce it to just the disambiguating signals) — the input patterns are currently stated twice, costing tokens without adding guidance.
Add one short worked example of a completed Type I or Type II outline so the expected output shape is shown, not just listed as required sections.
Make step 4 of the workflow concrete (e.g., '2-3 subpoints per section covering mechanism, evidence, limitation') and add a recovery action for when the Completion Checklist fails, mirroring the existing fallback contract.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is list-based and free of concept re-teaching, but the 'Type Recognition Rules' section substantially duplicates the 'When to Use' input patterns (e.g., 'topic keywords', 'observations or findings', '`Title:`' each appear twice), and the 'Optional Validation Shortcut' section adds marginal value. This fits 'mostly efficient but includes some unnecessary explanation or could be tightened'; it is not a 4 because the duplication is a whole section rather than minor instances, and not a 2 because there is no padding or explanation of things Claude already knows. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is concrete for an instruction-only skill: exact required-section contracts per type, literal refusal templates, a real executable command ('python scripts/validate_skill.py --check'), and input examples for all three types. It is not a 5 because there is no worked example of an actual output outline, so 'specific examples cover the common cases' is only partially met; it is not a 3 because the guidance is directly executable as written, not pseudocode or high-level hints. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The workflow gives a clear 5-step sequence with checkpoints (step 1 validates domain and sufficiency, step 5 is a final safety pass), a fallback contract with retry formats, and a completion checklist — matching 'clear sequence with most checkpoints present'. It is not a 5 because there is no feedback loop after the final pass (nothing tells Claude what to do if the checklist fails) and step 4's 'Enrich with academic logic' is underspecified relative to the other steps; it is well above a 3 because validation checkpoints are explicit rather than implicit. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is well-organized with clear section headers, and its single bundle reference ('scripts/validate_skill.py') exists and is correctly signaled. It is not a 5 because at ~215 inline lines with all type rules, contracts, and examples in one file, some content (e.g., the three output contracts or the example inputs) could be split out, and the 'Optional Validation Shortcut' section sits oddly before 'When to Use'; it is not a 3 because there is no misplaced bulk content and navigation is easy. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |