Content
56%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is authoritative and well-bundled — every referenced reference, template, and script path resolves to a real file (except the schematic generator), and workflows carry regulatory timelines. Its central weakness is that SKILL.md is the whole textbook rather than an overview: roughly 80% of the content restates material already in references/ and assets/, at severe token cost, and the mandatory-figure section depends on a missing script and an external skill.
Suggestions
Cut SKILL.md to an overview + TL;DR + workflow + resource index, moving the inlined CARE checklist, HIPAA identifier list, and per-report-type section anatomy into the existing reference/template files they duplicate.
Remove or soften the "MANDATORY scientific-schematics" section: scripts/generate_schematic.py is absent from the bundle and it hard-depends on an external skill not shipped here.
Add one executable usage example per validation script (e.g. "python scripts/validate_case_report.py draft.md") and insert an explicit run-validation checkpoint into each report workflow.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~1,150-line body is a textbook inlined into SKILL.md: full CARE checklists, the 18 HIPAA identifiers, SOAP/H&P/discharge section anatomy, ICH-E3 section lists, and standard nomenclature (SNOMED/LOINC/ICD-10) — all concepts Claude already knows and all duplicated in the bundled reference files. Genuinely skill-specific nuggets (7/15-day SAE timelines, Joint Commission do-not-use abbreviations, turnaround benchmarks) are diluted by heavy padding, fitting 'noticeably verbose; several unnecessary explanations or padded sections'. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is concrete: exact template paths ("assets/soap_note_template.md", "assets/clinical_trial_csr_template.md"), validation scripts named per task ("scripts/validate_case_report.py", "scripts/check_deidentification.py"), worked report excerpts, and regulatory timelines. Not a 5 because the only literal command shown, "python scripts/generate_schematic.py", targets a script that does not exist in the bundle, and no usage examples (arguments, expected output) are given for any of the eight real scripts. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Multi-step workflows are clearly sequenced with realistic timeframes (case report Phases 1–6 by week, SAE "24 hours to 15 days", CSR "6–12 months") and include review checkpoints (Phase 4 internal review, CSR QC review) plus a Final Checklist. Not a 5 because validation is generic — "Validation scripts are available in the scripts/ directory" — rather than wired in as an explicit validate-then-fix step at a defined point in each workflow. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The bundle structure itself is excellent — all 8 references, 12 assets, and 8 scripts referenced in the body exist on disk, are one level deep, and are catalogued with descriptions in the Resources section. But the split is undermined by massive inlining: the ~900 lines of CARE/radiology/pathology/ICH-E3/SOAP textbook in SKILL.md duplicate the dedicated reference files, matching 'content that should be separate is inline'. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |