Content
48%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The skill has a genuinely strong workflow design — explicit readiness gating, a 9-step sequence, and a mandatory output structure — but the body is heavily redundant, lacks concrete examples (markers, PubMed queries, output templates), and leaves 40% of its reference bundle unreferenced. It is a solid draft that needs consolidation and example material rather than a redesign.
Suggestions
Consolidate the redundant sections: merge Task/Core Function, Scope Boundary/What This Skill Should Not Do, Hard Rules/Formatting Expectations, and Input Validation/Step 1 into one statement each to roughly halve token cost without losing content.
Add one concrete mini-example: a sample citation-marker usage and a sample PubMed search query (e.g., `("heart failure"[Title] AND biomarker[Title]) AND review[Filter]`), and reconcile the hardcoded Chinese marker "强烈建议插入文献" with references/citation-marker-note.md, which requires an English-only skill body.
Update Reference Module Integration to list all bundle files, merging the duplicated handoff-rule.md into handoff-to-logic-builder-rule.md and adding pointers to paragraph-role-control-rules.md and study-positioning-and-claim-boundary-rules.md.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body states the same rules three to four times across sections: the redirect to Introduction Logic Builder appears in Task, Scope Boundary, Reference Module Integration, Input Validation, Step 1, Step 8, output sections A and I, Hard Rule 3, and Quality Standard; Hard Rules, What This Skill Should Not Do, and Scope Boundary largely restate each other; Mandatory Output Structure and Formatting Expectations overlap. This pervasive redundancy goes beyond "some unnecessary explanation" (anchor 3) and matches "noticeably verbose; several unnecessary explanations or padded sections" (anchor 2). | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | There is concrete guidance — a 9-step execution flow and a mandatory A-I output structure — but key executable details are missing: no example of a citation-support marker in use, no sample PubMed search query, no example of a well-vs-poorly-written gap statement, and no template showing what a final output looks like. Additionally, the hardcoded Chinese marker "强烈建议插入文献" contradicts references/citation-marker-note.md, which requires the skill to stay fully in English with the marker managed outside the skill. This fits "some concrete guidance but incomplete; missing key details" (anchor 3) better than anchor 4's "minor gaps". | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Steps 1-9 give a clear sequence with explicit checkpoints: the input-sufficiency check (Steps 1-2) gates drafting, and the Writing Readiness Decision (output section C) forces a ready/partially-ready/not-ready verdict before the draft (section D) is produced, with Step 7 and section H covering residual-uncertainty flagging. Not anchor 5 because there is no explicit error-recovery loop (e.g., what to do after follow-up questions are answered) and the sufficiency criteria are listed but not operationalized; not anchor 3 because the gating checkpoints are explicit rather than implicit. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The Reference Module Integration section clearly signals six one-level-deep reference files with their purposes, but four of the ten bundle files are never referenced from SKILL.md (paragraph-role-control-rules.md, study-positioning-and-claim-boundary-rules.md, handoff-rule.md, citation-marker-note.md), leaving substantive rules unreachable via navigation; handoff-rule.md also duplicates the referenced handoff-to-logic-builder-rule.md. Per the guideline to score against the actual bundle structure, the buried 40% of the bundle is more than a "minor organization gap" (anchor 4) and matches "some structure... references present but not clearly signaled" (anchor 3). | 3 / 5 |
Total | 12 / 20 Passed |