Content
60%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured body with a clear five-step workflow, concrete search commands, and real bundle files. The main weaknesses are duplicated workflow content across sections, an example CSV that conflicts with the actual provided template, and missing executable guidance for the vector/PageIndex retrieval paths it advertises.
Suggestions
Align the example CSV output with assets/hit_list_template.csv — the body's example uses English headers (file_path,location,snippet,relevance_score,notes) while the template uses Chinese headers (来源文件,位置,命中片段,相关性评分,备注) — either fix the template or the example so the claimed compatibility is real.
Merge the "Example Usage" steps with the "Implementation Details" section, which currently repeat the same workflow (index confirmation, query strategy, ranking, citation resolution), nearly halving the body length.
Add an explicit validation checkpoint in step 5 (e.g., verify each snippet traces back to the cited location and the hit list matches the template columns before saving) and integrate guide.md's quality check into the workflow.
Provide an executable method or explicit fallback for vector index and PageIndex retrieval, which are currently advertised but have no runnable commands.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | No generic filler explaining concepts Claude already knows, but the document duplicates its own workflow: the "Example Usage" steps and "Implementation Details" sections each cover index detection, query/synonym strategy, filtering/ranking, and citation resolution, and "Key Features" overlaps "When to Use". Fits "mostly efficient but could be tightened"; not 2 because every section carries skill-specific guidance rather than padding. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Provides concrete executable commands (glob patterns, `grep -RIn "API key\|key rotation\|rotate" ./kb/`) and a worked CSV example, but key details are missing: vector index and PageIndex retrieval have no executable method (assumed external tooling), and the example CSV headers (file_path,location,snippet,relevance_score,notes) do not match the actual assets/hit_list_template.csv columns (来源文件,位置,命中片段,相关性评分,备注) despite the body claiming compatibility. Fits "some concrete guidance but incomplete"; not 4 because the template mismatch and unexecutable retrieval paths are more than minor gaps. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Five clearly sequenced steps with an explicit error-recovery fallback ("If indices are missing/corrupted, fall back to direct file scanning; if scanning is not possible, report the limitation and required remediation") and a relevance-filtering checkpoint in step 4. Not 5 because there is no checkpoint verifying the saved hit list against the template columns or confirming snippets trace back to sources; not 3 because the sequence and fallback loop are explicit. The read-only nature of the skill means the destructive/batch cap does not apply. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Both referenced bundle files exist (references/guide.md, assets/hit_list_template.csv) and are clearly signaled in Dependencies, one level deep. Not 5 because guide.md largely duplicates body content (output formats, checklists) rather than adding depth, and detailed implementation content (ranking weights, citation resolution rules) remains inline in the ~120-line body despite a references file being available; not 3 because references are clearly signaled and shallow. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |