Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is well-structured with a clear workflow, concrete budgets, and a refusal/recovery contract, but it duplicates its own deliverable lists and package guidance while leaving the entire references/ directory and the QC script undiscoverable. Progressive disclosure is the weakest area: the skill bundles five detailed guides that SKILL.md never points to.
Suggestions
Add a short 'Deep references' section pointing to the existing references/ files (e.g., package comparison -> references/latex_poster_packages.md, layout -> references/poster_layout_design.md) and wire scripts/review_poster.sh into the final quality checklist, so the bundled detail is actually discoverable.
Merge the deliverables triple-listing (Core Deliverables, Writing Output Contract, Workflow step 5) into one canonical list and fold the 'If the user does not specify a package' block into the Package Decision Matrix to remove the duplication.
Add an intermediate validation checkpoint after the compression step (e.g., verify the section copy totals fit the 300-800 word A0 budget before planning figures) to complement the existing final checklist.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | There is no over-explanation of concepts Claude already knows, but the deliverables are listed three times ("Core Deliverables", "Writing Output Contract", and Workflow step 5), the package guidance in "Package Decision Matrix" is duplicated by the "If the user does not specify a package" block, and "Final Quality Checklist" overlaps the bundled poster_quality_checklist.md. Mostly efficient but could be tightened, matching the 3 anchor; it is above 2 because nothing is concept-level padding, and below 4 because the structural redundancy is more than minor. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, executable instruction-guidance throughout: exact budgets ("A0 poster: usually 300-800 words total", "2-4 results bullets", "no more than 5-6 major content blocks"), a copy-paste refusal template, and a decision matrix with explicit defaults. Minor gaps: how to actually apply the assets/ templates (e.g., copy the matching template and fill sections) and the orphaned scripts/review_poster.sh are never wired into the workflow, so it does not reach fully-executable 5. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The five-step workflow is clearly sequenced and ends in an explicit validation gate ("Final Quality Checklist: Before returning") plus a Refusal and Recovery contract as an error-recovery path. It is below 5 because checkpoints are missing between steps (e.g., verifying the compressed narrative against the word budget after step 3) and the recovery contract covers refusal rather than a validate-fix-retry loop; this is a writing skill, so no destructive/batch cap applies. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The four referenced assets/ paths all exist and are well-signaled, but the body never references any of the five files in references/ (verified: no 'references/' paths in SKILL.md) — content like the inlined Package Decision Matrix is exactly what references/latex_poster_packages.md covers in depth — and scripts/review_poster.sh is entirely orphaned despite a checklist item about script requirements. References present in the bundle but not clearly signaled, with content that should be delegated kept inline, matching the 3 anchor. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |