Content
46%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The skill has a sound skeleton — a clear 3-step workflow and an appropriate one-level-deep reference file containing the concrete writing rules — but the body is buried under ~100 lines of generic template boilerplate, contains contradictory validation instructions, a broken cross-reference, and an unrunnable example path. Trimming the boilerplate and consolidating the validation guidance would substantially improve it.
Suggestions
Delete or drastically trim the generic template sections (Key Features, Implementation Details, Output Contract, Deterministic Output Rules, Completion Checklist) — 'Key Features' merely repeats the description verbatim and 'Implementation Details' is pure filler; keep only sections that carry task-specific content.
Resolve the validation contradiction: pick one story — either the 'Validation Shortcut' script run or the 'Quick Validation' claim that no script is needed — and make the script actually check something about the task (e.g., verify character limits from writing_guidelines.md) instead of just printing 'ok'.
Fix the broken navigation and example: change 'See `## Workflow` above' to point at the actual section location (or remove it), and replace the environment-specific path '20260316/scientific-skills/Others/multi-source-news-writer' with a repo-relative path that will resolve for users.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is noticeably verbose with several padded boilerplate sections: 'Key Features' repeats the frontmatter description verbatim ('Scope-focused workflow aligned to: Integrates multiple news sources...'), and 'Implementation Details' offers generic filler like 'Execution model: validate the request, choose the packaged workflow, and produce a bounded deliverable' that adds nothing Claude doesn't already know. The genuinely task-specific content (When to Use, Workflow, Rules, References) is only ~25 of 134 lines. Not a 1 because there is no fundamental-concept explanation (e.g., what a press release is) and the core sections are accurate. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | There is some concrete guidance: executable commands ('python scripts/validate_skill.py --help', verified present in the bundle), a real referenced guidelines file with 5W1H extraction, and a workflow step 'Produce the press release in the specified Markdown format'. But key details of the deliverable live only in the reference file, the 'Example Usage' path ('cd "20260316/scientific-skills/Others/multi-source-news-writer"') references an environment-specific directory that will not resolve, and no example input/output of a press release appears anywhere in the body. Not a 4 because the executable guidance has real gaps (broken example path, format only defined externally). | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The Workflow section lists a clear 3-step sequence (Analyze Inputs → Apply Guidelines → Generate Output) and a Completion Checklist exists, so the sequence is coherent. But validation checkpoints are muddled and contradictory: 'Validation Shortcut' says to run 'python scripts/validate_skill.py --help' while 'Quick Validation' states 'No local script validation step is required for this skill', and the script itself only prints 'validation-helper: ok' — it validates nothing about the actual task. There is no validate-and-fix feedback loop for the press-release output itself (e.g., checking character limits from the guidelines). | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The bundle structure is good: 'references/writing_guidelines.md' exists, is clearly linked in a References section, is exactly one level deep, and appropriately holds the detailed rules (character limits, output format) while SKILL.md stays an overview; 'scripts/validate_skill.py' also exists and is referenced by its real path. Not a 5 because navigation is degraded by a broken pointer ('See `## Workflow` above' — the Workflow section actually appears *below* Implementation Details) and duplicated/contradictory validation sections that fragment the overview. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 12 / 20 Passed |