Content
67%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The core workflow, permitted-channel policy, pitfalls, and command-line guidance are concrete and actionable, with real executable scripts and sensible validation checkpoints. The main weaknesses are a substantial tail of generic boilerplate sections, a duplicated 'Failure Handling' heading, and one orphaned bundled script that the body never mentions.
Suggestions
Delete or heavily condense the generic boilerplate tail (When to Use / When Not to Use / Required Inputs / Output Contract / User Checkpoints / Input Validation / Quick Validation), keeping only skill-specific guidance — and merge the two 'Failure Handling' sections into one.
Document download_pmc.py's actual flags (--pmcid, --identifier, and any others) so the unified entry point is fully usable from the doc alone, and mention or remove the orphaned scripts/download_selected_pmc_pdfs.py.
Move the per-channel selection detail (E-utilities, OAI-PMH, FTP, Cloud Service usage) into a references/ file with example API calls, keeping SKILL.md as a lean overview.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The domain-specific sections (workflow, permitted channels, pitfalls, command usage) are lean, but roughly the last quarter of the file is generic template boilerplate ('When to Use', 'When Not to Use', 'Required Inputs', 'Input Validation', 'Quick Validation') with circular filler like 'Use this skill when the user explicitly needs to perform the core task of pmc-official-download', plus a duplicated 'Failure Handling' section. Mostly efficient with unnecessary padding that could be trimmed — the 3 anchor, not the 2 anchor, since there is no concept-explanation padding and the core content is tight. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Provides concrete, executable commands referencing real bundled scripts ('python scripts/download_pmc.py --pmcid PMC13011518 --pmcid PMC11656652', 'python scripts/download_pmc_bioc.py') plus verifiable checks (e.g., 'check if the file header starts with %PDF'). Minor gaps: E-utilities, OAI-PMH, and FTP guidance is prose-only with no example calls, and download_pmc.py's flags are shown only via examples rather than documented. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clear 4-step workflow (confirm needs → determine legality → select method → save with audit trail) with validation checkpoints for batch operations (user confirmation before batch, %PDF header verification, OA Web Service legality check) and an ordered troubleshooting sequence — the batch-validation cap does not apply since checkpoints are present. Not the 5 anchor because validation steps are scattered across 'Practical Pitfalls'/'User Checkpoints' rather than embedded in the workflow, and the duplicated 'Failure Handling' sections create mild ambiguity. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Well-sectioned body with clear headers and valid one-level-deep script references (both scripts/download_pmc.py and scripts/download_pmc_bioc.py exist and behave as described). Minor gaps: the third bundled script (scripts/download_selected_pmc_pdfs.py) is never mentioned or linked, and all channel-selection detail is inline in a ~230-line file where a channel reference file could offload content — good structure but short of the clean overview-plus-references pattern at 5. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |