Content
56%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The skill body delivers a genuinely actionable, well-sequenced workflow with strong mode-selection logic, explicit checklist validation, and a complete worked example. Its weaknesses are verbosity — the Mode A/B material is duplicated across three sections and known concepts are re-explained — and weak progressive disclosure, with detailed content inlined instead of split into the existing reference files.
Suggestions
Collapse the duplication: remove the "Key Features" section (its bullets are restated nearly verbatim in "When to Use" and in Processing Workflow steps 5–11), keeping one authoritative statement of the Mode A/B capabilities.
Move the detailed Mode B workflow steps, output templates, and the long example output report into references/guide.md, keeping a concise overview in SKILL.md with clear point-of-use pointers (e.g., "Output format: see [guide.md](references/guide.md)") instead of "when available"/"recommended" signaling.
Delete the explanations of concepts Claude already knows — the FAIR-letter expansion, direct vs. conceptual replication definitions, and the "Key Platforms and Tools" descriptions of GitHub/Zenodo/OSF — replacing them with just the names where operationally relevant.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body states the Mode A/B content three times — the "When to Use" list, the "Key Features" bullets, and Processing Workflow steps 5–11 which nearly verbatim duplicate the Key Features Mode B bullets — and explains concepts Claude already knows ("FAIR data management — Findable (persistent identifier, metadata), Accessible...", "direct replication (match original methods), conceptual replication (different methods, same hypothesis)", "GitHub / GitLab — Code version control and sharing"). This matches "noticeably verbose; several unnecessary explanations or padded sections" rather than 3 (only occasional tightening needed) or 1 (no elementary concept padding; most lines carry operational content). | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete guidance throughout: a 4-step Mode A workflow with priority rules ("High Priority: required to reproduce results"), a complete worked Example Usage showing both input template and full output report, enumerated Output Requirements, named platforms, and explicit mode selection logic ("If both types of input are present → run both modes sequentially"). As an instruction-only skill, absent code is not penalized; it is not 5 because some Mode B steps stay advisory ("Adopt open science badges", "Choose open access publication route") without concrete procedures, and not 3 because the guidance is specific and complete with a full example, not pseudocode-level. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Clear numbered sequences for both modes, an explicit validation step ("Checklist verification — Validate coverage of: sample size/replicates, randomization/blinding...") tied to assets/reproducibility_checklist.md, a trigger condition requesting the full Methods section, and error-handling feedback ("If required inputs are missing, state exactly which fields are missing and request only the minimum"). Not 5 because Mode B steps 5–11 have no verification checkpoints — they are advisory guidance with no way to confirm outputs — and not 3 because validation, sequencing, and error recovery are explicitly written out. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Bundle files exist (assets/reproducibility_checklist.md, references/guide.md) but are weakly signaled ("when available", "Dependencies: ... (recommended for ...)"), while the body inlines substantial content that belongs in those references — the ~30-line example output report, the full Mode B workflow detail, and Output Requirements that overlap with references/guide.md's output checklists and format. This matches "some structure but references present yet not clearly signaled; content that should be separate is inline" rather than 4 (clear point-of-use pointers, content appropriately split) or 2 (the body is well-sectioned and references are real and one level deep). | 3 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |