Content
70%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
An extremely actionable, well-sequenced orchestrator skill with strong validation checkpoints and feedback loops, undermined by verbosity (historical changelog-style notes, repeated rules) and by inlining hundreds of lines of templates that duplicate existing repo template files instead of living in a references/ bundle. The body is also internally inconsistent with the description on validator category count (4 vs 5).
Suggestions
Extract the full 04-validators.yaml and 05-guidelines.md templates (~350 lines) into a references/ directory and cite the existing docs/specs/templates/ files instead of duplicating them inline, keeping SKILL.md as an overview with only the structural rules.
Remove the historical/dated narrative ('Histórico: intentos previos...', 'formalized 2026-05-08', 'cement 2026-05-19') and consolidate rules stated multiple times (Playwright mandatory, agent-type non-existence) into a single authoritative location.
Fix internal consistency: define the validator ids referenced in scenario_coverage (e2e_edge_race, e2e_adversarial, a11y_axe, e2e_empty_state, e2e_network_failure, e2e_concurrent, e2e_large_dataset, e2e_locale_AR_MX_CL, fe_unit_voseo_check) in the template, and align the description's '4 categories' with the body's 5-category v4.1 mandate.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly dense, non-derivable project operational knowledge, but it is padded with historical narrative ('Histórico: intentos previos de spawnar... fallaron', 'formalized 2026-05-08 después del 2do uso exitoso', 'cement 2026-05-19') and repeats key rules several times (Playwright-mandatory at lines 105, 172, 334, 635; the 'architect-{be,fe,agentic} are not agent types' warning at lines 58-60 and 687). | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Highly concrete: a copy-ready spawn prompt, a full 04-validators.yaml template with executable pytest/playwright/npx commands, an owner-eligibility table, DAG dependency examples, and a closing checklist. Minor gaps: scenario_coverage references validator ids (e2e_edge_race, e2e_adversarial, a11y_axe, e2e_empty_state, etc.) that are never defined in the template's validators list, and the frontmatter says 4 validator categories while the body mandates 5 (architectural_validation). | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Nine clearly numbered steps with explicit validation gates ('Validation gate v4.1: Every scenario in 01-spec.md MUST appear en scenario_coverage AND test_construction_plan.scenario_to_test'), a checkbox checklist in Step 8, feedback loops (iteration on_fail/on_cap_reached, escalation to /pm and Chris), and an anti-patterns section — matching the top anchor. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The 9-step section structure is good, but there are no bundle files at all: roughly 350 lines of full templates (04-validators.yaml, 05-guidelines.md) are inlined in SKILL.md even though the body itself points to existing repo template files (docs/specs/templates/04-validators-template.yaml, 05-guidelines-template.md), duplicating content that clearly belongs in separate reference files. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |