Content
78%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-architected multi-agent workflow: fully executable synthesis command (verified against the script's real CLI), concrete quantitative specs at every step, and an exemplary progressive-disclosure layout with one-level references anchored to the steps that need them. The drag is conciseness — duplicated dependency lists, a redundant resource index, generic注意事项, and three examples that mostly restate the step list — plus the absence of an explicit validate-and-retry loop.
Suggestions
Cut the 使用示例 执行流程 lists that merely restate the 8 steps; keep only the differentiated parameters (duration, shot count, audience, style, sample copy) in a compact table, saving ~40 lines.
Drop the 前置准备 dependency block (already in frontmatter) and remove either the 资源索引 section or the inline step links, since they duplicate each other.
Add an explicit feedback loop after step 8: if validation (resolution/帧率/音画同步) fails, name the corrective action (e.g. re-run composer with adjusted --fps/--width/--height, regenerate the offending scene image) before finishing.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The step sections are tight and directive, but there is noticeable slack: the dependency block duplicates the frontmatter verbatim, the 资源索引 section re-lists reference links already given inline at steps 3/6/8, the 注意事项 section contains generic advice like "保持智能体间协作" and "必要时调整", and the three 使用示例 each spend ~8 lines restating the 8-step pipeline. Not a 2 because nothing explains concepts Claude already knows and the core instructions carry real information; not a 4 because the examples and resource-index redundancy could be cut with no loss. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is fully executable: a copy-paste bash invocation of scripts/video_composer.py whose flags (--images/--subtitles/--audio/--output/--fps/--duration) exactly match the script's actual argparse, plus concrete numeric specs throughout (titles 5-10 字, 1920x1080 minimum resolution, 8-12 shots per 30s video, ≤20 字 per subtitle line, output naming scene_001.jpg..., subtitles.json). Not a 4: nothing here is pseudocode or vague, and the examples cover the common 30s/60s/15s cases with concrete shot counts. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The eight steps are clearly sequenced, each with 职责/执行要点/输出, the chain rule is explicit ("每个步骤的输出应成为下一步的输入"), and there are checkpoints: pre-flight material verification in step 8 ("确保所有素材准备就绪") and output validation ("验证视频质量:分辨率、帧率、音画同步、字幕清晰"). Not a 5 because there is no error-recovery feedback loop — nothing says what to do when a generated image, subtitle timing, or the final render fails validation — and step-level self-checks in 注意事项 are stated only vaguely ("必要时调整"). | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is a proper overview with well-signaled, one-level-deep references that all exist in the bundle: storyboard_format.md linked at step 3, subtitle_format.md at step 6, video_specs.md at step 8, and scripts/video_composer.py invoked via bash, each linked exactly where needed with '格式参考'/'何时读取' cues. Formats are appropriately split out rather than inlined, and the 资源索引 provides navigation. Not a 4: structure and signaling match the best-practice example; the only cost of the resource index is mild duplication, which is a conciseness issue, not a navigation one. | 5 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |