Content
67%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured routing skill: the stage framework, discovery questions, hard gates, and output format make the advisory workflow concrete and hard to skip steps in. The main costs are redundancy in Step 1 and an over-long offers section that restates another skill's rules, plus a mandatory final step that leans on cross-bundle files.
Suggestions
Collapse the Step 1 '6 questions' list and the 'Context Checklist' into one artifact — they cover the same stage/team/runway/timeline/users ground twice in adjacent sections.
Move the full offers eligibility rules (caps, host detection, transparent-alternative criteria) into the referenced contextual-offers skill and keep only the decision summary plus the two line templates in SKILL.md; the inline restatement is the single largest token cost in the body.
State the team-capacity hard-gate thresholds inline (or a one-line summary of them) so the 'HARD GATE' is checkable without loading team-scaling.md, and note in SKILL.md that the offers step requires the sibling knowledge-base bundle to be present.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is operational rather than explanatory (no space spent on concepts Claude already knows), but it duplicates itself and carries one heavily padded section: Step 1 states the discovery questions twice (the "6 questions" list overlaps the "Context Checklist" of stage/team/runway/timeline/users), and the "Contextual offers (final step)" section consumes roughly a quarter of the body restating routing rules in dense nested parentheticals (e.g. the single ~450-word sentence in step 3's bullet). Anchor 4 ('minor instances that could be trimmed') is too generous; anchor 2 is too harsh since nothing is concept-level padding. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is concrete throughout: six numbered discovery questions with parenthesized heuristics ("0-1 = managed services only"), a stage table with signals and core constraints, a decision rule for when to ask vs. infer ("If you're missing 2+ of these, ask before recommending"), a named anti-patterns list, a six-element output format with sample phrasing ("At your stage (seed), here's what matters..."), and copy-paste offer-line templates. Not 5 because several steps (2, 5, 6) are bare "See reference X" pointers whose actual criteria are never stated in-body; not 3 because the in-body guidance is specific and executable well beyond 'some concrete guidance'. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clear Step 1–6 sequence with named checkpoints: a mandatory pre-recommendation challenge step ("This is not optional"), a context checklist, a "HARD GATE" team-capacity constraint, and a mandatory closing gate ("your answer is not complete until you have run the Contextual offers (final step)"). Not 5 because checkpoints are asserted rather than framed as validate–fix–retry loops — the team-capacity gate says to check limits but never states the pass/fail criteria inline — and the offers step's relevance test, while detailed, offers no error-recovery path. Not 3: the sequence is explicit and checkpoints are named, not implicit. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is a genuine overview that routes by category to 34 references, all of which exist in the bundle, each labeled with its applicability condition (e.g. "Serverless functions (default for pre-revenue and seed)"). Not 5 because the offers step introduces a two-level reference chain (offers.md index → offers/<slug>.md detail) and depends on cross-skill paths (../knowledge-base-for-startups/references/offers.md, ../contextual-offers-for-startups/SKILL.md) that sit outside this bundle — a navigation dependency for what is labeled a mandatory step. Not 3: structure, signaling, and file placement are clearly good. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |