Lists multiple specific concrete actions: parse natural language into a DAG, auto-inject checkpoint save nodes, confirm with user, persist as reusable JSON template. These are detailed, concrete capabilities.

The 'what' is well-covered with specific actions. The 'when' is limited to command triggers ('wf-composer' or '/wf-composer') rather than describing natural use cases or scenarios. It doesn't have a 'Use when...' clause describing situations like 'when the user wants to create a multi-step workflow' or 'when chaining multiple skills together'.

Includes the command triggers 'wf-composer' and '/wf-composer', but lacks natural language keywords users would say like 'workflow', 'pipeline', 'automate', 'chain tasks', 'DAG'. The triggers are command-based rather than natural language terms.

Highly distinctive with a clear niche — semantic workflow composition into DAGs with checkpoint injection. The specific command triggers and unique domain (workflow DAG composition) make it very unlikely to conflict with other skills.

The skill is reasonably efficient and doesn't over-explain basic concepts, but includes some structural overhead that could be tightened (e.g., the shared constants table, the entry router table). The phase descriptions are concise but the overall document has moderate verbosity for what amounts to delegating to sub-files.

Each phase delegates to external files (phases/01-parse.md, etc.) with brief summaries of objectives and success criteria, but the SKILL.md itself contains no executable code, no concrete commands, and no copy-paste ready examples. The pipeline visualization is a good concrete example, but the actual execution details are deferred entirely to referenced files that aren't provided.

The multi-step workflow is clearly sequenced across 6 phases (0-5) with explicit success criteria for each phase, checkpoint injection rules, a confirmation/validation phase (Phase 4) with user approval before persisting, and resume/edit capabilities. The feedback loop in Phase 4 (edit → re-enrich → re-confirm) is well-defined.

The skill references phase files (phases/01-parse.md through phases/05-persist.md) and spec files (specs/node-catalog.md, specs/template-schema.md) for deeper content, which is good progressive disclosure structure. However, none of these referenced files exist in the bundle, making it impossible to verify they support the content. The references are one-level deep and clearly signaled, but the missing bundle files prevent a score of 3.