Content
78%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A strongly engineered workflow body — fully executable commands, precise dispatch and routing, and clean one-level progressive disclosure over a real reference bundle. Its main weakness is token efficiency: duplicated cost/model guidance across two sections, retained design-history rationale, and time-sensitive version details that belong in a single, trimmer block.
Suggestions
State the model-cost guidance once (either the intro or the 'Why this is a separate skill' section) and cut the duplicated provider/window details, dropping the historical model-pin explanation entirely.
Remove or heavily shrink the 'Why this is a separate skill' section — it justifies design decisions to maintainers, not instructions the executing model needs; if kept, isolate the version-sensitive model numbers (Haiku 5.5/4.5, window sizes) in a clearly marked section so they age visibly.
Add a validation branch to step 1 mirroring the input-path check: what to do when audit-extract.py exits nonzero or digest.scope is not one of session/project/instance (e.g., report the error and stop), closing the workflow's remaining checkpoint gap.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The dispatch, steps, and output-contract sections are tight, but the body repeats the model/provider cost guidance almost verbatim in the intro and again in "Why this is a separate skill", retains historical rationale ("a hard model pin capped the usable context… broke invocation on long sessions") and a whole justification section the executing model does not need. It also carries time-sensitive version numbers (Haiku 5.5 / 4.5, 1M / 200k windows) outside any deprecated/old-patterns section — matching the "mostly efficient but includes some unnecessary explanation" anchor, not the level-4 anchor whose over-explanation is only minor. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Everything is copy-paste executable: the exact helper invocation `python3 scripts/audit-extract.py $ARGUMENTS[1] --mode $ARGUMENTS[0]`, literal-equality dispatch on $ARGUMENTS[0], exact accepted file patterns, a verbatim usage message to print, exact output paths with derived <id8>/<ts> tokens, and an explicit write order ending with the two `[audit] saved →` lines. This matches the fully-executable anchor; the only deferred detail (findings content) is correctly delegated to the playbooks. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Steps 1–5 are clearly sequenced with an input validation checkpoint (missing/nonexistent path → print usage and stop) and an explicit write order, but there is no branch for the extract helper failing or `digest.scope` being unexpected, and no verify step for the written artefacts. This sits at "clear sequence with most checkpoints present; minor validation gaps" — above level 3 (which lacks checkpoints) but short of level 5's explicit error-recovery loops; the destructive/batch cap does not apply since the skill only reads input and writes new files. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is a genuine overview: a dispatch table and scope-routing table point to five real one-level-deep playbooks (all present in references/), organized per scope/mode with a closing reference listing, plus the extract script. Sibling cross-links between playbooks (e.g. detailed-audit.md ↔ quick-audit.md) stay one level from SKILL.md, matching the well-signaled clear-overview anchor. | 5 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |