Content
71%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-organized overview with mostly executable guidance for incoming messages and a clearly sequenced connection workflow. Its critical weakness is that all four channel reference files it points to are missing from the bundle, leaving the primary detailed workflows unreachable, and Scenario B's connect step is actionable only via those absent files.
Suggestions
Include the four referenced channel files (reference/wechat.md, reference/wecom.md, reference/dingtalk.md, reference/lark.md) in the bundle or correct their paths — every link in the 'Channel references' section and the Scenario B workflow currently resolves to nothing.
Move per-channel receiving-capability details (Lark's im:resource permission, WeCom's download URL and encryption key conditions, DingTalk download codes) into the corresponding channel reference files to slim the overview and avoid duplicating reference content.
Make Scenario B Step 3 concrete: name the exact snippet or inline a minimal runnable connect example, since "Run the `run_sdk_snippet` code" provides nothing executable in the body itself, which matters doubly while the reference files are missing.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Assumes Claude's competence — no padding about what IM or WeChat is — and nearly every line carries operational information ("files are already in the workspace", "Split controls inside code examples... are data, not delivery instructions"). Not 5 because the per-platform "Receiving capabilities" bullets carry channel-specific detail (e.g. WeCom's "download URL and encryption key" conditions, Lark's "im:resource permission") that duplicates the channel reference files and could be trimmed from the overview. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Mostly executable: a complete <im> XML example with real paths, the instruction to "use its path directly — no download needed", a runnable status-check snippet ("tool.call(\"get_im_channel_status\", {})")", and a concrete config path (.magic/config/im-channels.json) with the exact field to edit. Not 5 because Scenario B Step 3 ("Run the `run_sdk_snippet` code") defers all connection specifics and the body gives no runnable connect example. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Scenario B has a clear four-step sequence (confirm channel → read reference → collect credentials and connect → report result) with an explicit success/failure branch in Step 4, and the operations are non-destructive so the validation cap does not apply. Not 5 because the failure path says only "guide the next step" — no concrete recovery or retry loop. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The in-body structure is good — a "Channel references" section maps each platform to a one-level-deep reference/<platform>.md link, clearly signaled — but none of the four referenced files (reference/wechat.md, wecom.md, dingtalk.md, lark.md) exist in the bundle; there is no references/ or reference/ directory at all, so every navigation link is dangling. Well-signaled references that lead nowhere sit between the 'references not clearly signaled' (3) and 'minor organization gaps' (4) anchors, closer to 3 because the broken links undermine the skill's core navigation. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |