Content
81%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is an exceptionally actionable, well-sequenced review procedure with executable commands, explicit validation checkpoints, and recovery instructions for the failure modes it guards against. Its weaknesses are repetition — the report-shape rules are restated three times where a single statement plus cross-references would do — and a miscounted reference ("Eight" sections vs the ten actually listed and shipped).
Suggestions
Correct the count in 'The rest of the checklist': it says "Eight more sections live in references/checklists.md" but names ten, and references/checklists.md contains exactly ten sections.
State the heading-placement rules (summary sentence → Performance findings, counted number → Measurements, environment caveat → Sections checked) once in Step 0 and have the Step 2 mid-run check and the final check reference them, instead of re-explaining them three times.
Trim duplicated enforcement prose such as the repeated 'never rewritten / read it back first' warnings and restatements like "Routing widens attention; it never narrows it. A grep hit is a reason to open a section, never a reason to stop reading." to reduce the body's token cost.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The four-heading placement rules are explained three separate times — Step 0 ("a summary sentence goes at the top of `## Performance findings`, a number you counted goes in `## Measurements`, an environment caveat goes at the end of `## Sections checked`"), again mid-run in Step 2's shape check, and again in "Check the file before you finish" ("a summary sentence belongs at the top of `## Performance findings`, a number you counted in `## Measurements`, an environment caveat at the end of `## Sections checked`"). Mostly efficient otherwise — no padding with concepts Claude already knows — but the triplicated rules and rhetorical restatements ("Routing widens attention; it never narrows it") go beyond the 'minor instances' of the 4 anchor. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Every step is copy-paste executable: the heredoc that writes the report skeleton, the base-branch resolution block (`BASE=$(git config --get branch.$(git branch --show-current).gh-merge-base || echo main)`), the grep routing table with literal patterns, the `grep -c '^## …'` shape checks with expected output ("It must print `4`"), and `grep -rn '<gateName>(' <workspace>/src/routes` for counting callers. Not 4: nothing is left as pseudocode or high-level hint. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The process is explicitly sequenced (Step 0 skeleton → Step 1 route → Step 2 work sections → report shape → final check) with validation checkpoints and error-recovery loops at both mid-run ("If it prints less … restore the 4 headings, put the finding back under the right one, and edit from then on") and completion (both grep counts "must print `4`"). This matches the 5 anchor's explicit validation with feedback loops. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The split is appropriate and well signaled — "Eight more sections live in `references/checklists.md` … open the file whenever Step 1 routes to one of them" — and the referenced file is real and one level deep (verified: it exists and contains the routed checklist sections). But the text says "Eight more sections" while naming ten (Loops and batching, Indexes, Unbounded reads, Effect runtime, Client fetches, SolidJS reactivity, Bundle and loading, Layout and event handlers, Build and deploy, Changesets — ten in the reference file too), and the main body still inlines two full checklist sections, leaving a minor organization gap per the 4 anchor rather than the clean 5. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |