Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A lean, well-sectioned orchestration skill with a genuinely strong per-phase validation-and-rollback loop and thoughtful safety carve-outs (the delete-list immutable-constraint rule). Its main weaknesses are that executable detail is deferred to playbook/template files that do not exist in this bundle, and the promised outputs are described abstractly without a concrete example of a phase plan.
Suggestions
Ship the referenced bundle files (playbooks/spring-boot-2-to-3.md, playbooks/references/*.md, templates/migration-plan.md, policies/*.md) or inline the essential content — every deferred reference currently points to a file absent from the bundle.
Add a minimal worked example of one migration phase (objective, temporary compatibility strategy, validation criteria, rollback trigger) so the 'plano incremental' output is concrete rather than an artifact name.
Sequence the end-to-end workflow (assessment → plan → phase loop → handoff → review) as a numbered list, and merge the redundant delete-list categories 1 and 5 ('Código morto' vs 'Branches inalcançáveis').
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is efficient — short sectioned lists ('Quando Usar', 'Checklist Base', a compact playbook table) with no explanations of concepts Claude already knows, matching 'efficient; minor instances that could be trimmed'. It is not 5 because of redundancy: delete-list items 1 ('Código morto — branches/funções inalcançáveis') and 5 ('Branches inalcançáveis — condição sempre falsa/verdadeira, dead code após return/throw') overlap substantially, and the governance file enumeration could be tightened. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | There is some concrete guidance (the per-phase checkpoint 'rodar a suite de testes completa... executar o rollback documentado', and the delete-list evidence rule 'citar arquivo:linha... grep/symbol search sem match'), but the core migration execution guidance stays at the artifact level ('estrategia de compatibilidade temporaria explicita', 'rollback e criterio de corte documentados') with the actual steps deferred to playbook/template files that are not present in the bundle — matching 'some concrete guidance but incomplete'. It is not 4 because a reader of this file alone lacks the specific steps to produce the promised incremental plan. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The central phase loop is explicit with validation and a feedback path: 'aplicar a fase → rodar a suite de testes completa → se falhar, corrigir ou executar o rollback documentado... Só avançar quando a suite estiver verde', plus a base checklist — matching 'clear sequence with most checkpoints present'. It is not 5 because the end-to-end workflow (assess current state → build plan → phase loop → handoff → review) is never sequenced; only the per-phase loop is, and the validation applies to test suites rather than to plan artifacts. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | In-body structure is good and references are clearly signaled (a playbook table with 'Quando usar' and one-line descriptions of `playbooks/references/common-fixes.md` and `custom-parent-strategy.md`), but every deferred target — `playbooks/`, `playbooks/references/`, `templates/migration-plan.md`, `policies/*.md`, `GLOBAL.md` — is absent from the actual bundle, so navigation dead-ends at runtime. This lands between 'references present but not clearly signaled' (3) and 'good structure; references mostly clear' (4): the signaling earns 4, the broken/missing bundle targets pull it back to 3. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |