Content
67%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured orchestration skill with genuinely operational gating criteria, output templates, refusal-routing loops, and user-sovereignty rules. Its weaknesses are localized: version-changelog tokens scattered through the body, a conformance-test stub section and duplicate Output Format heading, and core mechanics delegated to conventions files that are absent from the bundle.
Suggestions
Strip version annotations ('v0.25.1 gating', 'v0.25.1 extension', 'v0.27.x') from section headers and prose, or consolidate them in a short changelog/deprecated section.
Delete the trailing '## Output Format' conformance-test stub section and the duplicate of the existing '## Output format' section; merge related skills and output formatting into one place.
Resolve the dangling references: either ship the conventions files (cross-modal.yaml, model-routing.md) inside the skill bundle or inline the minimal routing-chain and model-selection details the workflow needs to execute, and use one consistent path format (currently '../conventions/...' and 'conventions/...' both appear).
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Most sections are tight operational bullets (gating thresholds, refusal-routing steps, anti-patterns), but there is real padding: version annotations appear in three places ('When to invoke (v0.25.1 gating)', 'Code-review handoff (v0.25.1 extension)', 'gbrain eval cross-modal command (v0.27.x)'), a multi-paragraph blockquote digresses on the sibling command's role, and a stub section at the end ('The literal section header here exists for the conformance test') is pure test-satisfying noise. More than 'minor instances' of over-explanation, so not 4; but it never explains concepts Claude already knows, so not 2. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, usable guidance throughout: quantified gating criteria ('5+ files or 100+ lines', '2+ iterations'), verbatim output templates with the exact framing blocks, numbered phases, and explicit do/don't lists. Not 5 because the core mechanics — how to actually spawn the second model and what review prompt to send — are fully delegated to conventions files that are not present in this bundle, and the 'Agreement: X% (N/M findings overlap)' template gives no method for computing the percentage. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The five phases are clearly sequenced with an explicit pass/fail grading checkpoint ('Pass / fail with specific citations'), a refusal-routing feedback loop (refuse → switch silently → escalate when all refuse), a dedicated 'When it fails' section, and invoke/do-not-invoke checklists. Not 5 because phase 3 ('Spawn review model') depends entirely on an external model-routing.md that does not exist in the bundle, and only refusal — not malformed or unusable reviewer output — has a defined recovery path. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Good structure with clearly signaled, one-level-deep markdown links ([conventions/cross-modal.yaml], [conventions/model-routing.md], [conventions/test-before-bulk.md]) and well-organized sections. Not 5 because the actual bundle is a single SKILL.md with no referenced files present — the routing chain and model-selection details live entirely in dangling external paths, section headers are duplicated ('## Output format' at line 138 vs '## Output Format' at line 202), and the ~40-line Codex/adversarial mode detail plus the conformance-test stub section could live in a reference file. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |