Provides structured code review against plans and standards. Use when a feature is complete and needs validation, when reviewing code before merge, or when assessing quality and test coverage—e.g., "finished step X", "ready for review", "validate architecture", "check quality and tests".
89
87%
Does it follow best practices?
Impact
89%
1.71xAverage score across 3 eval scenarios
Passed
No known issues
Structured review output and announcement protocol
Opening announcement
0%
100%
Overview section present
50%
100%
Findings section present
28%
100%
Tests/verification section present
25%
100%
Final statement present
0%
100%
Severity closing count
0%
100%
Severity labels on findings
25%
100%
Location field on findings
50%
100%
Rationale field on findings
50%
100%
Fix field on findings
75%
100%
Severity ordering
85%
100%
Plan alignment addressed
100%
100%
Domain checklist use and architecture review
Strengths acknowledged
55%
77%
Architecture assessment present
70%
90%
Frontend-specific accessibility finding
100%
100%
Frontend-specific component design finding
100%
100%
Frontend performance concern raised
37%
0%
Documentation/standards check present
44%
77%
Rationale on every finding
77%
100%
Code examples in fixes
100%
100%
Overview is concise
100%
100%
Verification suggestions included
0%
100%
Final statement present
0%
100%
Opening announcement present
0%
0%
Plan alignment and finding format completeness
Plan alignment first
30%
70%
Deviation identified
100%
100%
Database transaction concern
100%
100%
Missing index finding
100%
100%
Migration reversibility finding
100%
100%
Fix with code example
100%
100%
All files reviewed
100%
100%
Severity labels used correctly
0%
100%
Rationale on every finding
100%
100%
Closing count statement
0%
100%
Final statement present
0%
100%
Opening announcement present
0%
0%
b74de5e
Table of Contents
If you maintain this skill, you can claim it as your own. Once claimed, you can manage eval scenarios, bundle related skills, attach documentation or rules, and ensure cross-agent compatibility.