Content
35%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body presents an elaborate, internally consistent protocol whose sequence and invariants are genuinely specified, but at extreme token cost: the same rules are restated across five sections, the core guidance is abstract with no worked example, and the huge formal block is inlined rather than pushed to a reference. An executing model gets the philosophy but little concrete help producing an actual assessment.
Suggestions
Move the Lean formal block to a reference file (e.g., references/contract.md) and keep in SKILL.md only the step sequence, the rules, and pointers, cutting the body by roughly two-thirds.
Add one worked example — a short source/target mapping with the correspondences, one check with its defeater, and the resulting verdicts — so the abstract directives become executable.
Eliminate the repeated restatements by choosing one home per rule (the Rules section) and referencing it from FLOW, CONVERGENCE, and the Lean doc comments, and either link references/best-practices.md from the body or fold it into the activation heuristics.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The 631-line body restates the same rules many times over — the Lean formal block, the FLOW comment, the CONVERGENCE block, the Protocol section, and the Rules section each re-express 'warrant tracks evidence, never assent', the question-standing rule, and the collection rule. Not 1: the content is a novel protocol rather than explanations of concepts Claude already knows, but the redundancy across five restatements is heavy padding. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | The guidance stays at the level of abstract directives ('collect to the limit of your reach over what the mapping rests on', 'construct the correspondences') with no worked example of an actual audit, no sample assessment output, and no concrete case showing verdicts in practice. Not 1: the morphism does give a named step sequence (question → collect → construct → check → warrant → judge → surface) and the Intensity table specifies output formats, which is more than pure description — but the executing model is left to infer nearly everything concrete. | 2 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A real sequence exists (question read/draft → collect → construct → check → warrant → judge → surface) with the protocol's own check concept serving as an internal validation mechanism and explicit re-read rules on each new utterance. Not 4: the sequence is buried inside a Lean formalization and dense prose, checkpoints are implicit in the contract's semantics rather than stated as operational steps, and there is no error-recovery guidance for the practical workflow. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Three real reference files exist and the ones referenced are one level deep and clearly signaled ('references/judgments.md' is section-linked from four axioms, 'references/round-composition.md' is gated on a stated occasion). Not 4: references/best-practices.md is never referenced from the body, and the ~560-line Lean formal block — content that clearly belongs in a separate reference file — is inlined wholesale into SKILL.md. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 10 / 20 Passed |