Content
57%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a well-written, lean router: it classifies the work into two clearly defined flavors, gives a concrete fallback question, and lists precise firing conditions and guardrails. Its critical weakness is that all three files it delegates its core content to (correction-driven.md, informative-capability.md, placement.md) are missing from the bundle, leaving the actual voice, process, and placement guidance unavailable.
Suggestions
Ship the three referenced files in the bundle (e.g., under references/): the body routes to correction-driven.md, informative-capability.md, and placement.md, but none exist, so the skill's core voice/process and placement guidance is unreachable.
Inline a one-or-two-line summary of each referenced file's key guidance (e.g., the headline rule for correction voice vs informative voice) so the skill remains actionable even when a reference fails to load.
Add a post-edit validation checkpoint to the workflow, such as re-reading the edited rule in its target file to confirm placement and voice, or confirming the landing location with Josh before finishing.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is lean, assumes Claude's competence, and explains nothing Claude already knows — sections carry real payload (classification criteria, concrete file paths, guardrails). One or two sentences are motivational rather than instructional ("classifying wrong is the single biggest way this skill gets misapplied", "The two flavors look superficially similar..."), keeping it at the 4 anchor's 'minor instances that could be trimmed' rather than the 5 anchor's every-token-earns-its-place. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete guidance exists — explicit classification criteria, a literal fallback question ("Is this you correcting a behavior, or you wanting me to know about a capability?"), and exact paths like `claude/CLAUDE.md` and `claude/agents/implementer.md` — but the core execution details (the voice and process for each flavor, placement rules) are deferred to `correction-driven.md`, `informative-capability.md`, and `placement.md`, none of which exist in the bundle. That matches the 3 anchor ('some concrete guidance but incomplete; missing key details') rather than the 4 anchor's minor gaps. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The entry sequence is clear and ordered ("Before touching anything, identify which kind of work this is" → load the flavor-specific file → decide placement via `placement.md`), and there is one explicit checkpoint (ask Josh if unsure). But everything after the routing step is opaque because the referenced files are absent, and there is no validation of the edited artifact, fitting the 3 anchor ('sequence present but checkpoints missing or implicit') better than the 4 anchor's 'most checkpoints present'. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The SKILL.md itself is well structured with clear sections and one-level-deep, clearly signaled references ("Load **`correction-driven.md`** before editing"), which would suggest a 4. However, none of the three referenced files exist anywhere in the bundle (no references/ directory), so the disclosure chain is broken and the promised detail is unreachable — structure is present but incomplete, matching the 3 anchor. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |