Content
75%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured, token-efficient instruction skill: explicit gates, concrete validation commands, a failure-mode checklist, and a references section whose files all exist one level deep. The main gaps are redundancy across the Gotchas/Execution Boundaries/Validation lane-separation rules, policy statements mixed into the numbered workflow, and unlabeled reference entries that give no guidance on when to open each file.
Suggestions
Collapse the repeated lane-separation rule (Workflow step 12, Execution Boundaries, and the closing Validation paragraph) into a single stated-once rule to remove redundancy and earn a conciseness 5.
Add a one-phrase purpose label to each References entry (e.g., 'gold-scenario-contract.md — scenario authoring rules; tessl-tile-scenario-contract.md — Tessl tile asset format') so readers can route to the right file without opening all twelve.
Separate the 12-step Workflow into a strictly ordered gate sequence, moving authoring policies (steps 5–10) into a 'Authoring rules' subsection so the actual execution order is explicit.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and assumes Claude's competence — no known concepts are explained, and sections like Failure Mode and Validation are terse checklists. It is not 5 because the lane-separation rule is repeated nearly verbatim across Workflow step 12, Execution Boundaries, and the closing Validation paragraph, and Gotchas partially restate Execution Boundaries — trimming that redundancy would make every token earn its place. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | The Validation section gives eight copy-paste-ready commands with exact flags (e.g., `./bin/ask sdk eval scenario-quality <skill-path> --preview --json --robot`), and steps name exact artifacts (`instructions.json`, `scenario-N/{task.md,criteria.json,capability.txt}`). It is not 5 because several workflow steps are policy directives without an executable action (e.g., "Treat Tessl rejection as a pipeline defect…", "Feed repeat failures back to the start of the pipeline") — they say what to decide, not the command or edit to make. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The 12-step workflow lays out an ordered pipeline with explicit validation gates ("Run package verify, scenario-quality, scorer-quality, and scorer-calibration before oss-local…"), a feedback loop (step 4), a Failure Mode stop-checklist, and a Validation section. It is not 5 because the numbered list interleaves sequencing with authoring policies (steps 5–10 are rules, not steps), so the true execution order is partly implicit and a reader must reconstruct when each policy applies. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is a concise overview with one-level-deep references, and every listed path (evals.yaml, contract.yaml, gold-scenario-contract.md, tessl-registry-boundaries.md, sdk-pipeline-setup.md, knowledgeos-handoff-conversion.md, etc.) exists in references/. It is not 5 because the References section is a bare unlabeled path list — no per-file purpose labels or routing guidance (e.g., which contract to read for Tessl tiles vs. eval repair), unlike the 5 anchor's '**Form filling**: See [FORMS.md](FORMS.md)' pattern. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |