Content
56%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body delivers an exceptionally well-gated, checkpoint-rich workflow with concrete commands and decision rules, but at roughly twice the token budget the task needs: rules are duplicated, prose walls justify each instruction at length, and cross-references to undefined rules (10–13, 6) leave parts of the gating logic unresolvable. It reads as three full skills concatenated rather than one streamlined composite, as its own overview claims.
Suggestions
State each rule once: the grep-the-old-name guidance appears nearly verbatim twice in Phase 2 step 2, and the parent-worktree/never-stash prohibitions are restated across steps 2b and 8b — keep the first statement and reference it elsewhere.
Resolve the dangling rule references: "Rule 10", "Rule 11", "Rule 12", "Rule 13", and "Rule 6" are cited but the <rules> section defines only 1–6 — either include the full rule list or inline the operative text at each citation site.
Split the JiT sub-workflow (steps 2b, 3d/3e, 8a/8b and the parent-worktree lifecycle) into a single referenced file with a short trigger condition in the main body — it is a self-contained subset whose bulk drives most of the file's token cost.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is pervasively padded: step 2b and the Parallel Delegation bullet are multi-hundred-word prose walls, rhetorical asides abound ("A question followed in the same breath by 'pushing now' is not a question, it is an announcement"), and rules are restated nearly verbatim — the grep-the-old-name rule appears twice in Phase 2 step 2, and the parent-worktree prohibitions recur across steps 2b and 8b. Not 3: the verbosity is constant rather than occasional; not 1: it never explains concepts Claude already knows and most text is operative instruction. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is largely executable — exact commands ("git worktree add <SCRATCH>/jit-parent-<sid> <parent-sha>", "git diff --stat"), an explicit first-match verdict-selection order, a concrete report template, and push-safety checks. Not 5: the text cites "Rule 10", "Rule 11", "Rule 12", "Rule 13", and "Rule 6" but the <rules> section defines only rules 1–6, leaving those citations dangling; not 3: the bulk of the guidance is directly executable, not high-level hints. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Three phases are strictly sequenced behind an explicit verdict gate ("Only Approve proceeds to Phase 2"), with validation checkpoints throughout (empty-diff guard, "Verify Unchanged State", the dual-run filter ensemble, the two pre-reset checks before `git reset --hard`) and a closing verification checklist. Not 5: the undefined Rule 13 reference sits inside the verdict-selection logic itself, so part of the gating cannot be followed from this file alone; well above 3: checkpoints and error-recovery fallbacks are explicit and pervasive. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | No bundle files exist — all three inlined workflows live in one ~350-line monolithic file, which is a deliberate, justified design ("Self-contained — execute the inlined steps directly, do NOT invoke other skills") but still leaves phase-scale content inlined that could be split. Internal structure is strong (phases, <step_by_step> blocks, rules, verification), so above anchor 2's "minimal structure"; below anchor 4 because nothing is organized into separate files. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |