Content
82%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A high-quality conventions skill: concrete APIs, code, timings, and decision tables with explicit validation guidance, and no filler. The main weakness is the 'Assignment routing' section, a dense prose wall of edge-case rules that hurts both conciseness and the overview structure a single-file skill should keep.
Suggestions
Move the 'Assignment routing' detail (host cycling, hedging timings, CSP/CORS notes) into a separate reference file (e.g. references/assignment-routing.md) and keep a 3-4 line summary in SKILL.md, preserving the overview-plus-one-level-reference structure.
Rewrite the remaining routing prose as short bullets ('Try hosts in order: enterprise → business → individual; 1s hedging during discovery only; 5s total deadline') so each rule is scannable instead of buried in run-on sentences.
Add a brief end-to-end checklist for the most common task (e.g. add setting schema → set `experiments.override.<treatment>` locally → verify the default resolves → add trigger → test both arms), including how to confirm a local override took effect.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense with repo-specific facts and never explains concepts Claude already knows, and the trigger sections are tight. Not 5 because the 'Assignment routing' section packs dozens of rules into long run-on prose ('Remember the winning host for the window and try it first on subsequent refreshes without time-based hedging; it fails over only on an error...') that could be bulleted and trimmed, and a few rationale sentences ('Dilution only costs statistical power, while a biased trigger gives wrong results') could be cut. Not 3 because there is no padding or filler anywhere. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is executable throughout: copy-adaptable calls (`logSettingExperimentTrigger(telemetryService, MY_SETTING_ID);`), a concrete local-override example (`"experiments.override.config.chat.mySetting.enabled": true`), exact schema snippets (`experiment: { mode: 'auto' }`), specific APIs (`IWorkbenchAssignmentService.getTreatment<T>`, `IExperimentalSettingsService.requestKeys`), concrete hosts/timings, and a named test service (`TestExperimentTriggerTelemetryService`). The common cases are covered with real code and a correct-vs-incorrect ordering example. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Decision flows are clear: three control patterns each with 'use this when' guidance, a when-to-use/when-to-fire structure, a decision table, a pitfalls checklist, and explicit validation ('Test each trigger in every arm with `TestExperimentTriggerTelemetryService`'; 'start a new experiment iteration'). Not 5 because there is no end-to-end sequence for the primary task (add experiment → verify override locally → add trigger → test), and the local-override path gives no way to confirm the assignment took effect. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | No bundle files exist; the body is a single well-sectioned SKILL.md whose two external links ([experimentTrigger.ts], [copilot-instructions.md]) are clearly signaled and one level deep. Not 5 because the body exceeds 50 lines and the ~450-word 'Assignment routing' architectural detail is inlined reference material that would serve better as a separate file, leaving SKILL.md an overview. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |