Content
75%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A dense, expert-facing skill body: executable tool calls with parameter-level gotchas, a concrete scoring rubric, and edge-case fallbacks, organized into a clear phase pipeline. The main gaps are a duplicated Chronos threshold note, missing call syntax for two phases, and an unverified cross-skill script dependency standing in for a proper bundle reference.
Suggestions
Consolidate the Chronos threshold guidance, which currently appears twice in Phase 1 (in the Classification line and again in the DepMap per-cell-line paragraph), into a single statement.
Add copy-paste call syntax for Phase 0 (Input Processing) and Phase 5 (Literature/PubMed) to match the executable detail given for Phases 1-4.
Clarify the cross-skill dependency on 'tooluniverse-cell-line-profiling/scripts/depmap_gene_dependency.py' — either verify it exists when this skill is installed, or bundle a local fallback script under scripts/ — and add explicit per-phase validation checkpoints (e.g., require hits to pass Phase 1 validation before Phase 2 enrichment).
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Lean and dense throughout — tool signatures, thresholds, and edge cases with zero concept explanations — earning a 5, except the Chronos threshold guidance is stated twice ('Chronos < -0.5 = likely essential, < -1.0 = strongly essential' and again 'Chronos < -0.5 ≈ dependency, < -1.0 strongly essential' two paragraphs later). This minor duplication places it at the 4 anchor: efficient with a small trim opportunity. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Tool calls are copy-paste ready with exact parameter quirks (STRING 'carriage-return separated', 'civic_search_evidence_items(molecular_profile=gene) -- NOT query', bash examples for the DepMap script) plus a concrete 0-18 scoring table. Not 5: Phase 0 (Input Processing) and Phase 5 (Literature) give no call syntax, so specific examples do not fully cover the common cases. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clearly sequenced 7-phase pipeline with error-recovery paths ('gnomAD overloaded: Retry once, proceed without, note gap'; 'Gene not in DepMap: Fall back to gnomAD + UniProt') and a tiered scoring checklist. Not 5: there are no explicit per-phase validation checkpoints before proceeding (e.g., confirming hits passed Phase 1 validation before pathway enrichment) — checkpoints are implicit in the guiding principles. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Good section structure (principles, phases, edge cases, limitations) with everything inline and appropriate for a ~100-line single-file skill; no bundle files exist to navigate. Not 5: the only file pointer is an unverified cross-skill dependency ('tooluniverse-cell-line-profiling/scripts/depmap_gene_dependency.py', not present in this bundle), and the dense tool-API syntax is reference material that could be split out. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |