Content
75%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-engineered pipeline skill: lean, tool-specific, and clearly sequenced, with genuine progressive disclosure of details to reference files. The main weaknesses are the unverifiable/missing reference files in the bundle, no inline example invocations, and error-recovery loops being deferred entirely to a reference file.
Suggestions
Ship the five referenced files (tool-reference.md, report-template.md, integration-scoring.md, response-formats.md, use-patterns.md) in the skill bundle — SKILL.md currently points to files that are not present, breaking the progressive-disclosure path.
Add one or two complete example tool invocations with literal arguments (e.g., STRING_get_network(identifiers=['APOE'], species=9606)) to make the body's guidance copy-paste ready rather than deferred to tool-reference.md.
Inline a brief fallback loop for the most common failure (tool returns null/empty — e.g., the noted OpenTargets MONDO-vs-EFO ID issue) instead of delegating all error handling to use-patterns.md, so mid-pipeline recovery is visible in the workflow itself.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and assumes domain competence — no explaining what GWAS, PPI networks, or enrichment are; every line carries tool names, parameter formats, or phase requirements. Not 5 because the conceptual paragraph 'Multi-omics disease characterization asks: what molecular layers are dysregulated?...' is inference Claude could make, and the 13-item KEY PRINCIPLES list partially restates phase content. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Highly concrete, executable guidance: exact tool names with exact parameter requirements ('gwas_search_associations (use efo_id...not free-text disease_trait)', 'STRING_get_network (param: identifiers, species=9606)', 'ReactomeAnalysis_pathway_enrichment — identifiers are newline-separated', 'search_clinical_trials: query_term is REQUIRED'). Not 5 because no complete example invocations with literal arguments appear in SKILL.md itself — those are deferred to tool-reference.md and response-formats.md — so the body alone is not fully copy-paste ready. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Nine phases are explicitly sequenced with Phase 0 marked 'ALWAYS FIRST', an ambiguity checkpoint ('If ambiguous, present top 3-5 options and ask user to select'), and Phase 8 report verification backed by a mandated completeness checklist (principle 12). Not 5 because mid-pipeline error-recovery feedback loops (e.g., null/empty tool responses, fallback strategies) are not stated in the body — they are delegated to use-patterns.md — leaving a minor validation gap between the start and end checkpoints. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Textbook structure: concise overview, critical parameter pitfalls kept inline, and a Reference Files table clearly signaling five one-level-deep files, each with a stated purpose, plus inline pointers like 'See integration-scoring.md for full details'. Not 5 because the five referenced files (tool-reference.md, report-template.md, integration-scoring.md, response-formats.md, use-patterns.md) are not present in the skill bundle alongside SKILL.md, so the navigation points to files that could not be verified to exist. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |