Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-structured, actionable research pipeline with concrete tool invocations and useful lookup tables. Weaknesses are moderate verbosity (duplicated evidence grading, significance column restating known biology), missing examples for Phases 0/3/4, and a monolithic layout with no progressive disclosure into reference files.
Suggestions
Cut the 'Biological Significance' column from the KEGG pathway table and state the evidence-grading scale once — remove the duplicate between 'Key principles' and 'Phase 4' — to tighten conciseness.
Add short executable examples for Phase 0 (POWO/Ensembl species-and-gene identification) and Phase 3 (EnsemblCompara_get_orthologues), matching the Phase 1/2 style, so every phase is actionable.
Move the KEGG pathway table and crop organism-code table into a references/ file (e.g., references/kegg-codes.md) and point to it from SKILL.md, keeping the body a lean overview.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The tool table, KEGG pathway IDs, and organism-code tables are dense and useful, but padding exists: a 'Biological Significance' column restating known biology ('Light reactions, electron transport', 'CO2 → sugar'), exposition of facts Claude already knows (wheat ~17 Gb, hexaploid AABBDD, Arabidopsis as the model), and evidence grading T1–T4 stated twice (Key principles #5 and Phase 4). Mostly efficient with several sections that could be tightened, matching the 3 anchor. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, executable tool calls with real arguments are provided ('ensembl_lookup_gene(gene_symbol="CHS", species="arabidopsis_thaliana")', 'KEGG_get_pathway_genes(pathway_id="ath00941")', 'UniProt_search(query="CHS AND taxonomy_id:3702 AND reviewed:true")') alongside lookup tables of organism codes and pathway IDs. Not a 5 because Phases 0, 3, and 4 have no worked examples — Phase 0 exists only as a one-line diagram entry. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clear five-phase pipeline (Species ID → Gene Function → Pathway → Cross-Species → Literature) is diagrammed with per-phase detail, and 'LOOK UP DON'T GUESS' acts as an explicit verification checkpoint (confirm KEGG codes via kegg_search_pathway; check UniProt reviewed entries). This is a read-only research workflow so the destructive/batch cap doesn't apply; it misses 5 only for lacking feedback loops and thin Phase 0/3 step detail. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The ~140-line SKILL.md has clear section headers but is a monolith with no bundle files at all; the KEGG pathway table, organism-code table, and evidence-grading framework are inline content that could be split into reference files so the overview stays lean. Structure exists but organization could be meaningfully better, matching the 3 anchor. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |