Content
60%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body delivers strong, concrete, live-verified tool guidance (database coverage, parameters, edge fields, per-tool gotchas, and explicit workflows), but it is undermined by a missing bundle: both referenced files (python_implementation.py, KNOWN_ISSUES.md) do not exist, so the progressive-disclosure structure is broken and the promised runnable examples are unavailable. Additionally, several 'Domain Reasoning' sections teach generic biochemistry (valency/avidity, coiled-coils, detergents, amyloid clearance) unrelated to the skill's tools and inflate the token budget.
Suggestions
Fix progressive disclosure: either add the referenced python_implementation.py and KNOWN_ISSUES.md files or remove the dead references, and split the extended tool catalogs (SIGNOR, EBI Proteins, Extended Analysis Tools) into one-level-deep reference files with clearly signaled links from SKILL.md.
Trim conciseness: remove or compress the textbook 'Domain Reasoning' sections on multimeric binding statistics, coiled-coil prediction, detergent effects, and protein-identification trivia — Claude already knows this biochemistry, and none of it is specific to the ToolUniverse tools.
Improve actionability: inline at least one complete runnable example (imports, ToolUniverse setup, a full call sequence) for the 4-phase workflow so users are not dependent on the missing python_implementation.py.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Most of the body is lean and tool-specific (database table, parameter tables, edge-field definitions, verified gotchas like "ComplexPortal_get_complex can return complex_id: null"), but roughly a quarter of it (~50 lines) teaches textbook biochemistry Claude already knows: "Avidity vs affinity", Hill/Scatchard plot explanations, heptad-repeat coiled-coil packing rules, mild-vs-harsh detergent effects, and an amyloid-clearance trivia section. This matches 'Mostly efficient but includes some unnecessary explanation or could be tightened' — not score 2, since the padding is confined to discrete sections rather than pervading the document, and not score 4, because entire off-topic sections (Multimeric Assemblies, Coiled-Coil, Detergent Effects, Protein Identification) explain concepts unrelated to the skill's tools. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is mostly executable: concrete calls with parameters and example values such as "SIGNOR_connect_proteins(proteins=["P00533", "P28482"], level=2)", "ComplexPortal_search_complexes(query=..., species=..., number=...)", a copy-paste snippet "interaction_ids = result.get("metadata", {}).get("interaction_ids", [])", and verified output expectations. It stops short of 'fully executable / copy-paste ready covering common cases' because "See python_implementation.py for runnable examples (example_tp53_analysis(), analyze_protein_network())" points to a file that does not exist in the skill bundle — the promised runnable examples are not actually available — and there is no import/setup context for the ToolUniverse functions. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The core "4-Phase Workflow" is clearly sequenced (identifier mapping → network retrieval → enrichment → optional structural data), Complex Portal and SIGNOR each get their own explicit multi-step flows, and the Troubleshooting section provides recovery feedback loops ("No interactions found: verify protein names (case-sensitive), try confidence_score=0.4"; "BioGRID not working: set BIOGRID_API_KEY"). It sits at 'Clear sequence with most checkpoints present; minor validation gaps' rather than 5 because validation checkpoints are advisory and scattered (e.g., check escore for binding evidence) rather than formalized as explicit gates in the workflow steps themselves. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The skill has no bundle files at all (no references/, scripts/, or assets/), yet the body points to "python_implementation.py" and "(see KNOWN_ISSUES.md)" — both nonexistent, i.e., broken references. Meanwhile ~230 lines are inlined monolithically, including extended tool catalogs (the SIGNOR section with its tables and workflows, the EBI Proteins/Gotcha sections, Extended Analysis Tools) and textbook domain sections that clearly belong in separate reference files. This matches the anchor 'Minimal structure; content that clearly belongs in separate files is inlined; or references are buried' — the section headers give some structure, but the split-file organization the document itself assumes is not actually present. | 2 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |