Content
56%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body carries genuinely valuable non-obvious knowledge (live-verified ProteomicsDB behaviors, quantified minimums, decision trees, evidence grading) organized in a clear gated 8-phase workflow, but it pads token budget with textbook protein-ID/PTM explanations, defers all core analysis procedures to a PHASE_DETAILS.md that is missing from the bundle, and provides no executable code for the main analysis.
Suggestions
Trim the textbook concept explanations in 'Protein Identification Reasoning' and the PTM section (PMF mechanics, what MS/MS scoring is, PTM definitions, stoichiometry basics) that Claude already knows; keep only the workflow-specific thresholds, decision trees, and evidence grading.
Fix the dangling reference: either ship PHASE_DETAILS.md in the skill bundle or inline the essential per-phase procedures in SKILL.md — currently the detailed half of the workflow ('See [PHASE_DETAILS.md](PHASE_DETAILS.md) for detailed procedures per phase') points to a nonexistent file.
Add one minimal executable example for the core DE workflow (e.g., a pandas/scipy snippet implementing the stated 2+-unique-peptide filter and Benjamini-Hochberg correction) so Phase 2-3 guidance is copy-paste ready instead of a capability list.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Mostly efficient but padded in places: the 'Protein Identification Reasoning' section explains textbook MS concepts Claude already knows ('Peptide mass fingerprinting (PMF): Intact protein digested → measured peptide masses compared against theoretical digest', MS/MS scoring, protein inference), the PTM section opens with definitional material ('PTMs (phosphorylation, ubiquitination, acetylation, glycosylation) add biological complexity beyond protein abundance'), and the 'Comprehensive analysis of mass spectrometry-based proteomics data...' paragraph restates the header. The genuinely non-obvious material (verified-live ProteomicsDB gotchas, quantified minimums, evidence grading) does earn its tokens, but the whole could be tightened — anchor 3 fits better than 4 because the textbook explanations are more than a minor trim. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | There is concrete guidance — the exact CLI form `tu run read_executed_notebook '{"data_folder":"<path>","search":"<keyword>"}'`, a tool-by-tool table with field-level caveats ('expression_value (log10-normalized, cross-tissue-comparable) vs. unnormalized_intensity (NOT comparable across tissues; never rank on this field)'), and numeric thresholds ('localization probability > 0.75', 'FDR < 0.05 standard'). But the core analysis phases offer only capability lists ('Limma, DEP, MSstats for statistical testing') and defer all procedures to 'See [PHASE_DETAILS.md](PHASE_DETAILS.md) for detailed procedures per phase' — with no code or steps for import/preprocessing/DE in the body, key execution details are missing (and the referenced file is absent from the bundle). Not below 3: the guidance that is present is specific and usable, not vague hints. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clear 8-phase pipeline ('Phase 1: Data Import & QC ... Phase 8: Generate Report') gated by an explicit pre-check branch ('Only follow this skill's re-analysis recipe below if **none** of the above exist'), with quantified checkpoints acting as validation gates ('At least 3 biological replicates per condition (non-negotiable for reliable statistics)', 'Filter to proteins with 2+ unique peptides', plus differential-expression strength tiers and evidence grading). Not 5: there are no explicit error-recovery/feedback loops and per-phase validation detail is delegated to a missing file. Not 3: the sequence and most checkpoints are present and explicit. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body is well-sectioned and its one reference is clearly signaled twice ('See [PHASE_DETAILS.md](PHASE_DETAILS.md) for detailed procedures per phase' and again under 'Reference Files'), but scored against the actual bundle: no references/, scripts/, or assets/ directories exist and PHASE_DETAILS.md is nowhere in the workspace, so the skill's single primary disclosure pointer dangles and the detailed half of the workflow cannot be loaded. The ~20-line ProteomicsDB tool reference is also inlined. Good in-file structure with a broken, load-bearing reference lands between anchors 2 and 3. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |