Content
70%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The content delivers an exemplary phase-gated workflow with explicit validation, feedback loops, and a Definition of Done, plus concrete numeric guidance throughout. Two real weaknesses: the progressive-disclosure architecture is unfulfilled in the shipped bundle (16 of 17 referenced rule/template files are missing, leaving every phase gate pointing at a nonexistent file), and the body carries noticeable structural redundancy (duplicated file tables; principles and anti-patterns restating phase gates).
Suggestions
Ship the referenced files or inline the critical ones: all 16 rules/*.md files and templates/cursor-spotlight.html are absent from the bundle, so every workflow phase gate and the brainstorm catalog point to files that cannot be loaded — either include them or move the essential rules (five brainstorm questions, safe-property table, duration/easing bands) into the body.
Merge the "Required Reading by Phase" table into the Workflow table (e.g., as a Files column) — it duplicates the same 17 rule-file paths already linked there, costing roughly 20 redundant lines.
Deduplicate the anti-patterns and core principles against the phase gates: the 200 ms loader floor, brainstorm-before-you-pick, and composite-only rules each appear two to three times across Core Principles, Anti-patterns, and the Workflow gates — keep each rule in one canonical location and link to it.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and free of concept-explaining padding, but carries structural redundancy: the "Required Reading by Phase" table repeats the same 17 rule-file paths already linked in the Workflow table, and the 15 anti-patterns plus 9 core principles restate content from the phase gates (the 200 ms loader floor, brainstorm-before-pick, and composite-only rule each appear two to three times). Not 4 because the duplicate table and repeated rules are more than minor trimming; not 2 because there is no fluff or explanation of things Claude already knows — every line carries signal, just repetitively. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, executable decision guidance throughout: a 12-row signal-to-tool table with "First match wins", specific numeric constraints ("transform, opacity, and filter only", "150–500 ms band", "exit ~30 % faster", "200 ms loader floor"), and concrete commands (Skill("screencast") invocations with recording.json parameters). Not 5 because the body contains no copy-paste code — the flagship brainstorm workflow's catalog and five-question framework live in rules/interaction-feedback.md, whose content is not available in this bundle; not 3 because the inline guidance is concrete and complete at the decision level for the common cases. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The phase table (A, B, 0–7.6) gives a clear ordered sequence with an explicit gate per phase, explicit validation (Phase 7: "60 fps in DevTools Performance; no purple Layout / green Paint bars"), a genuine feedback loop (Phase 7.6: "apply the fix and return to Phase 7.5. Cap the loop at 3 iterations — escalate... on the 4th"), graceful degradation for missing helper skills, and a Definition of Done checklist. This matches the anchor: clear sequence, explicit validation, error-recovery loops, and a checklist; no destructive/batch cap applies. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Scored against the actual bundle: of 17 internal file references, only references/recipes.md exists — the rules/ directory (16 files: safe-properties.md, interaction-feedback.md, modern-css.md, etc.) and templates/cursor-spotlight.html are absent, so the load-on-demand architecture cannot actually load. The in-body structure and signaling are excellent (would merit 5), but the bundle does not back it. Not 4 because 16 missing referenced files is far beyond a minor organization gap; not 2 because the body itself is well-organized with clearly signaled references, not a monolith or buried links. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |